Home
Q&A
False Cognates - Cognados Falsos

False Cognates - Cognados Falsos

8
votes

Let's see who can find the most interesting false cognates. These are words in our new language that would seem to have the same meaning as they do in our first language. I once came accross the word "suburbio," and I thought it would mean the same as "suburb" in English, but it acutally means "shanty town." These meanings are quite different, so they are false cognates. Have you come accross any of these? Please try to respond in both Spanish and English.

Vayamos a ver quién puede encontrar los cognados falsos mas interesantes. Éstos son palabras en nuestra idioma nueva que parecería tener el mismo sentido que ellos hacen en nuestra primera lengua. Me encontré con la palabra -suburbio,- pensé que significaría el mismo como -suburb- in inglés, pero esto realmente significa el -barrio de chabolas.- Estos sentidos son completamente diferentes, así que son cognados falsos. ¿Han encontrado alguna de éstas? Por favor trate de responder tanto enspañol como inglés.

10601 views
updated Aug 7, 2012
edited by RiCrow
posted by RiCrow
Love the question... can't think of my favorites right now. - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 3, 2012
Good question. Hopefully there will be a lot of answers. - 0095ca4c, Aug 4, 2012
Hairsplitter here. *Technically*, your example, suburbio/suburb, is not a case of false cognates. That's called "false friends". Suburbio and suburb *are*, in fact, cognates - they both stem from the same Latin word - but have since come to mean slightly- - inkubzz, Aug 6, 2012
-different things. An example of false cognates would be mucho/much (their etymologies are entirely disparate). ;) Sorry about this, I just wanted to clear it up. I *love* the thread otherwise. Great job! ;) - inkubzz, Aug 6, 2012
Thanks for the clarification inkubzz. - RiCrow, Aug 7, 2012
Yeah, that's useful to know. - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 7, 2012

21 Answers

5
votes

Hay muchos ejemplos:

un billón: in Spanish it means a trillion (1,000,000,000,000), and mil millones means a billion

una receta: In Spanish means a cooking recipe or medicine prescription, and recibo means receipt

últimamente: not ultimately (in the sense of finally) as we think in English, but rather "recently" or lately. a fin de cuentas or al final are good for saying finally in spanish.

le recomiendo a todo el mundo buscar por un libro que se llama "Breaking Out of Beginner's Spanish" escrito por Joseph J Keenan. Es un gran libro, y tiene un capítulo fantástico sobre este tema, el tema de los cognados falsos, o cómo se llama el autor "the tricksters" //// I recommend everyone look for a book called "Breaking out of beginner's spanish" by Joseph J Keenan. It's a great book, and it has a fantastic chapter on this topic, the topic of false cognates, or as the author calls them "the tricksters"

updated Aug 7, 2012
edited by DreSmith3
posted by DreSmith3
A billón in Spanish is a billion in English, it´s only a trillion in American... - afowen, Aug 6, 2012
eso es interesante! I did not know that afowen. supongo que este tema merezca su propia página ahora. I wonder how "billón" is used differently in Europe vs. LatinAmerica - DreSmith3, Aug 7, 2012
5
votes

This one can be a little confusing for a traveller.

dirección = address (not direction as you might suspect)

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by 0095ca4c
"Dirección" también se refiere a un rumbo o camino. Ej.: ¿En qué dirección debemos continuar? - -cae-, Aug 5, 2012
5
votes

Actual (the Spanish word, not the English word) is "current", "modern", or "present"


Los líderes de los países del mundo deben conocer los problemas actuales del mundo.

The leaders of the world's countries should be familiar with the problems of the world.

updated Aug 6, 2012
edited by Maxwell_R
posted by Maxwell_R
5
votes

Decepción

"Una decepción" is a disappointment, not a "deception" as one would think.

"Estaba muy decepcionada." (I was very disappointed)

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by --Mariana--
This is one of my favorites, if you can have favorite flase cognates. - gringojrf, Aug 3, 2012
ejemplo maravilloso, uno que todo el mundo de aprendedores del idioma español deben saber - DreSmith3, Aug 4, 2012
4
votes

embarazada is not "embarrassed"Ella está embarazada = she's pregnant Another one ester constipado means to have a cold

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by lagartijaverde
Very important distinction. - PumpkinCalabaza, Aug 4, 2012
Always liked this one - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 4, 2012
4
votes

Enterar = to find out or to get it/understand. Not to enter.

Also very similar is enterrar = to bury or forget

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by gringojrf
4
votes

Delito - crime

Fumar marihuana es un delito menor.

Smoking marijuana is a misdemeanor.

Actual (not actual) – current, present day

Licenciado – a law graduate, attorney

Editor (not editor) - publisher?

updated Aug 6, 2012
edited by viejito
posted by viejito
Nice contributions viejito - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 4, 2012
3
votes

To pretend y pretender

updated Aug 7, 2012
posted by kramer12
pretender: article & verb transitive 1. To pretend, to claim (afirmar), to solicit. - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 4, 2012
pretender does not mean to pretend if thats what you are trying to say - kramer12, Aug 6, 2012
I don't know the word well, it's not in my vocabulary.. but according to SpanishDict translator, is does mean 'to pretend'. - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 6, 2012
Its an error. pretender does not mean to pretend. it means to aspire to - kramer12, Aug 7, 2012
3
votes

efectivo = Cash (as noun) and Actual/Real (as adjective)

Quisiera pagar en efectivo - I would like to pay in cash.

Los resultados harán efectivos - The results will be carried out.

nb: while one of the definitions includes 'effective', it is a false cognate as a noun.

updated Aug 7, 2012
edited by yahvey_hoffman
posted by yahvey_hoffman
I wish that I had a bit more - "efectivo" haha:) - viejito, Aug 4, 2012
No doubt...:) - yahvey_hoffman, Aug 4, 2012
3
votes

Here's an example of false cognate confusion in practice. As LagartijaVerde mentions, 'Estoy constipado' means 'I've got a cold.', not... what you'd think...

So, an English guy who hadn't been in Spain very long was on his first date with a Spanish girl. She was lovely. She didn't speak English, but his Spanish was reasonable, if not great, and they were getting on very well until, out of the blue, she turned her big brown eyes on him and said ruefully, 'Estoy constipada.'

'Yuck!', he thought, 'Too much information!' and basically left as soon as possible, didn't phone her, etc.

Some time later, he told his story to a friend who had been here a bit longer, who promptly fell about laughing, and then explained False Cognate Number 1.

Oops.

Alguien me contó una pequeña historia de un problema con un cognado falso.

Como explica LagartijaVerde, en inglés 'Estoy constipado' significa 'I've got a cold.'

Adelante...

Un inglés recién llegado en España tiene su primera cita con una chica española. Quedan encontrarse en un bar un fin de semana. Ella es linda y muy simpatica, y a pesar de que no habla inglés, y que el inglés por su parte es principiante en español, se congenian. Pasen un buen rato hasta, de modo inesperado y con una mirada algo avergonzada, la chica dice al chico - Lo siento: estoy constipada.

El inglés está asombrado, y se pregunta as su mismo - ¡Puaj! ¿Porqué me cuenta del estado de sus intestinos? ¡Qué rara!

Y lo más pronto, se despide a ella, y después no la llama más.

Poco tiempo después, nuestro protagonista se encuentra con un amigo que ha pasado más tiempo en España. Le cuenta a él la história del fracaso con la chica rara. Y cuando su compañero acaba de reírse a carcajadas, le presente a Romeo ´El Cognado Falso Numero 1.'

¡Uy!

enter image description here

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by Enderby
Por favor, ¿corrija mi español? (Prefería que no hacerme en chimpancé.) - Enderby, Aug 4, 2012
Thats a very funny story. :) - viejito, Aug 4, 2012
3
votes

Estaba embarazada de cuatro meses . She was four months pregnant.

I was really embarrassed. Me dio mucha vergúenza.

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by ian-hill
That's a great answer, and it was really helpful that you highlighted the words! - RiCrow, Aug 4, 2012
2
votes

pariente - parent

Es pariente mio. / He’s a relative of mine.

My parents are Irish. / Mis padres son irlandeses.

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by ian-hill
2
votes

actual - actual

La situación actual del pais. / The country’s present situation.

The film is based on actual events. / La película está basada en hechos reales.

updated Aug 6, 2012
posted by ian-hill
1
vote

Careful with these false friends,

Actualmente = currently, presently, nowadays

Actually = en realidad, realmente, exactamente, de hecho

Últimamente = lately, recently

Ultimately = finally, eventually

updated Aug 5, 2012
edited by Eddy
posted by Eddy
1
vote

soportar - support

No lo soporto. / I can’t stand him.

My mum has always supported me. / Mi madre siempre me ha apoyado.

updated Aug 4, 2012
posted by ian-hill