Home
Q&A
Se llama - pronominal

Se llama - pronominal

1
vote

So, I was having a read of Lazarus' post here the uses of se and although the explanation about 'se llama' being pronominal makes sense on one level - 'mi madre se llama Carmen' she's called Carmen even if/though she doesn't call herself Carmen. I'm wondering about me llamo.

The next example given was 'se llama a sí mismo Superman' = reflexive - well that's all good, makes perfect sense - but can 'me llamo' be anything other than reflexive? And couldn't that mean that se llama without the 'a sí mismo' could just as easily be reflexive too?

alt text

5179 views
updated Oct 6, 2011
posted by Kiwi-Girl

3 Answers

1
vote

Yes, I see people and textbooks get the translation of "me llamo..." wrong all the time. I like to think of it as, "I am called..." It makes a little more sense, and isn't quite as awkward.

Again, it's just one of those things that you can't translate literally word for word.

updated Oct 6, 2011
posted by MrSillyInc
quite right :) - Kiwi-Girl, Oct 6, 2011
1
vote

but can 'me llamo' be anything other than reflexive?

Me llamo can be reflexive or , mainly, pronominal.

Me llamo Pepa...pero en el foro me llamo (a mi misma) heidita.

for examplewink

Me llamo does not mean I call myself...look up the article by lazaruswink

updated Oct 6, 2011
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

Ah thanx Heidi, I had missed that one - very good smile me llamo does not mean I call myself - by Lazarus

updated Oct 6, 2011
posted by Kiwi-Girl