Flagging unclear questions posted by new members
Dear fellow SpanishAddicts,
I have not been online regularly lately. So if any discussions with reference to this subject have already been posted, please forgive me for not noticing. I honestly can't keep up with the pace of the posts.
I just noticed a few posts by new members had been flagged immediately. Be it the questions were unclear or seen as spam. Although I understand that a "flag-button" is easily used I wonder why that is the case.
From the early days of my membership I have seen nothing else but new members being welcomed, and then directed to the forum rules or nicely explained why their post was seen as unacceptable. I find that a really good way to welcome any new members and helping them to get familiar with the site and its objectives. Most new members would quickly get the hang of it and start to participate in a positive, contributive way.
Just flagging posts without any accompanying explanation seems quite unfriendly and discouraging to me. I can't imagine that all of those flagged members even understand that they are flagged and why.
What are your thoughts on this?
Saludos, Chica
2 Answers
Chica,
I know which new posts and flags you are referring to and I don't think that an immediate flag was warranted. Although I did mark as "delete" for one of those posts, I sent a PM to the new member explaining why the question was inadequate.
Just flagging posts without any accompanying explanation seems quite unfriendly and discouraging to me....
I agree. If I flag something as "inaccurate" I will always put a comment as to why. Senior members, like Qfreed and me, would like to see the penalty removed from the "inaccurate" flag so that we could use it more often. I rarely use the flag for that very reason. Please read this post on the use of the "inaccurate and unclear" flag.
If I flag a post as "Needing Moderator attention" or "Obscene" I usually don't explain because the author of the post know exactly why it's been flagged. Often I will also mark that thread for deletion.
Dear Marianne,
Thanks for your input! I would support removing the penalty.
If I flag a post as "Needing Moderator attention" or "Obscene" I usually don't explain because the author of the post know exactly why it's been flagged. Often I will also mark that thread for deletion. Blockquote
I wholeheartedly agree with you on this point, some members post questions that just aren't "familyfriendly" to say the least.... I was mostly referring to posts that asked translation for misspelled phrases. Especially for beginners, correct spelling is obviously difficult.