Home
Q&A
G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

61
votes

Objective: practice in the use of the past tenses, preterite & imperfect

The rules:-----------------------------

  1. translate the English sentence given by the person above into Spanish using the correct preterite or imperfect verb conjugations

make sure you click on N E W E S T before you begin

Then

  1. state whether you used the preterite or the imperfect and give a short explanation as to why you used it

  • and finally
  1. provide a new sentence in English which includes a verb used in the past

for the next person to translate.

Have fun! ¡Diviértanse!

A suggestion: please keep your sentences simple. This is tricky stuff, so let's concentrate on the tenses, ok? - Gekko.

PS: here's a great link showing how the preterite is for action in the past whereas the imperfect is an ongoing condition in the past: Imperfecto vs Preterito and another that I've put together that may be of some use too, Pret vs Imp.

A big thanks to Gekko who 'was' kindly correcting this thread - Gekko if you have a mo' please post a thread below introducing yourself or post empty thread for me to introduce you, thus allowing the grateful participants to vote for all your hard and much appreciated work here wink

Edit - Sadly Gekko doesn't come round much anymore :( we'd love it if he did but in the meantime any corrections or suggestions are gratefully accepted and if someone would like to volunteer to help with moderation of this game, that'd be awesome, please just let us know so we can welcome you officially to the possie (as us antipodeans say (ie. position))

alt text

105508 views
updated Oct 25, 2014
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Maria Claire, this is a great idea! I wish you lots of takers - 005faa61, Aug 10, 2010
Muchisimas gracias :) thanx for joining in! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 10, 2010
So many views and so few posts? Come on guys just have a go - this is for learning and we're all here to help and be helped so have a crack :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Great idea Marie-Claire :) - --Jen--, Aug 11, 2010
What a "perfect" game!!! - --Mariana--, Aug 11, 2010
Muchisimas gracias a Maria, necesito mucha practica en el preterito/el imperfecto! - schemmn, Aug 11, 2010
Why I have seen this before my quiz last night?? Oh, well final exam is tomorrow and it will be on that, too! Muchas gracias! - chica_rica, Aug 11, 2010
Great game Maria!! I think I fixed all my mistakes! Thanks to Gekko for all his help. :) - Jason7R, Aug 11, 2010
Ok peeps, I don't know about you all but I feel like my understanding of the preterite and imperfect has improved out of sight in the just the last couple of days and I'd love to do similar threads with other things - por vs para, present vs subjunctive - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
etc, so I'm begging for moderators, please, pretty please. If out of the goodness of your heart you would consider volunteering please PM me, I know many of us would be sooooo grateful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Wonderful game MC and thanks to Gekkosan for all his help!!! - Izanoni1, Aug 18, 2010
I know, he's the bomb isn't he lol :) but don't tell him it'll probably go to his head je je Glad you're enjoying the game :) I've learnt heaps so far! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 18, 2010
Well done Maria, I never thought you'd get 100 answers for this. - fontanero, Aug 19, 2010
I think we all need so much help with it - have you joined in yet? Come on, give it a go, we're all getting heaps wrong, it's the best way to learn so don't be shy :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 19, 2010
Thank you Marie for you encouragement and to Gekkosan for patiently answering all my questions - sanlee, Aug 21, 2010
You're welcome :) My thanx too to Gekko, he's been very patient with us all and very, very helpful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 25, 2010
wonderful game, marie, thanks gekko too:) - 00494d19, Sep 1, 2010
Thanx Heidita,getting the idea was pretty easy but thanks to Gekko who's doing most of the hard work ;) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 2, 2010
A great idea, I've only discovered it a day or two ago.. Good one! - annierats, Jan 12, 2012

388 Answers

1
vote

Given:

I was eating a piece of fruitcake when my wife-to-be walked into the room and gave me the eye.

Translated:

Estaba comiendo un pedazo de pastel de frutas cuando mi futura esposa entró en la habitación y me lanzó una mirada torva.

Reason:

imperfect sets the scene - estaba comiendo

preterite - competed actions - entró & lanzó

New Sentence:

The clever creature ruminated on how to pose the hardest question possible.

updated Sep 22, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
The sentence is correct, but "esposa -a-ser" is not an expression in Spanish. You may use "futura esposa" instead. - 00e657d4, Sep 21, 2010
Hey!! I sense a dig in here somewhere! I'll be back soon to deal with you unruly lot! Sheesh, one just can't turn one's back for a minute, here!! - Gekkosan, Sep 21, 2010
what paranoia! as if .... :p - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 22, 2010
Thanx Guillermo, I didnt think I could get away with esposa a ser lol :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 22, 2010
One learns to be cautious, when surrounded by mischief makers! I like the "mirada torva" solution. Very elegant. - Gekkosan, Sep 22, 2010
To the first, probably a good plan. To the second, why thank you sir :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 22, 2010
1
vote

When I saw him, I couldn't believe how big he'd gotten.

Cuando lo vi, no podía creer cuánto había crecido.

Vi is preterit because it is completed past action; había is imperfect because ongoing past action still going on (still growing) podria imperfect

New Sentence

My parents met when they were in the Navy on a blind day and fell in love at first sight.; they were engaged six weeks later and have been married for sixty years.

updated Sep 20, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
Pretty good! No need for the subject pronoun. :-) ¡Cuando lo vi, no *podía* creer cuánto había crecido! - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
I found this one difficult, Gekkosan. So podia is preterit, too? - sanlee, Sep 20, 2010
podia is the imperfect tense Sandy :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010
Right M-C. You *could* say "no pude creer cuánto había crecido", but I think it's more natural this way. - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
the imperfect seems good if you could also say in English - I wasn't able to believe. The preterite is better for simple statements rather than phrases - I rang vs I was ringing - if that makes any sense! - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010
Thank you, Maria-Claire I was not certain of that tense, but it seemed more like imperfect - sanlee, Sep 20, 2010
Yes, that is a true tale about my parent, although they say they met at a "shipwreck party", it was still a blind date - sanlee, Sep 20, 2010
1
vote

Given:

I wanted to move to Mexico when I was a student of Spanish language.

Translated:

Quería mudarme a Mexivo cuando era estudiante de la lengua española.

Reason:

quería - imperfect emotional state

era estudiante - unknown duration

Question: I used 'era estudiante' because it seemed right, I know you use ser for professions etc in the present - is it right that you still use ser even though you are talking about the past with the definite feeling that you are no longer a student?

New Sentence:

I felt terrible when I realized that the children didn't ever have a chance to survive.

updated Sep 20, 2010
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Fine. - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
No please, don't be so effusive with your praise, I just can't take it! je je - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
Ooooh, poor Maria baby, she don't get nuff praise and huggies from the mean, nasty moderator? What a bad, bad lizard! :-) - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
lol I knew I'd cop something for that one :p - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010
1
vote

Did you enjoy the way that the dancers jumped so high? I liked the bit where they did cartwheels.

¿Disfrutó de la manera en que los bailarines salaban tan alto? Me gustó el fragmento donde hicieron volteretas. I think they are all preterit because the action has all been completed in the past. I am not sure of a lot of these words, but I am trying it anyway.

New sentence;

When we were first married, we made bookshelves out of wood and used them as dressers for our clothes by putting curtains on the front of them.

updated Sep 20, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
Essentially correct. Here's just a couple of suggestions for a more natural translation: "¿Disfrutó de la manera en que los bailarines salaban tan alto? Me gustó el fragmento donde hicieron volteretas. (No question mark). - Gekkosan, Sep 20, 2010
Thanks, Gekkosan. I couldn't get cartwheels to come out right and the sentence was a bit complicated for me. Thanks for the help! - sanlee, Sep 20, 2010
That was a great attempt Sandy, bien hecho! :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 20, 2010
1
vote

The boy got a smack because he was naughty.

El chico consiguió un bofetada porque era travieso.

Reason: The first part of the sentence is Preterite because the incident took place in the past and the second part is imperfect because here the person is being described in the past.

New Sentence: I wanted to move to Mexico when I was a student of Spanish language.

updated Sep 17, 2010
posted by Ashis
Good, but I would use "recibió" instead of "consiguió". Bofetada is feminine, so it should be "una bofetada". - 00e657d4, Sep 15, 2010
Again, an ambigous sentence where it could go one way of the other, depending on the interpetation. The way I read it, I would translate "he was naughty" in the preterite. Cause and effect. - Gekkosan, Sep 15, 2010
I think it would have to be the preterite unless it said something like, the boy was always getting smacked because he was naughty. - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 15, 2010
As Gekkosan said, it can be either way. The way you put it, I would think he was naughty allways, but that time he got a smack. - 00e657d4, Sep 16, 2010
sp. always :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
1
vote

GIVEN I was walking down the street when a woman jumped from behind a bush

ANSWER- yo estaba caminando por la calle cuando una mujer saltó de detrás de un arbusto

REASONS

  • (estaba) imperfect because it is occuring at that time.. no specefic ending..
  • (saltó) preterit because the action took place and ended at that moment

NEW SENTENCE when i was singing in my room, my father switch off the light

updated Sep 17, 2010
posted by hazyrra
Looks good to me, well done :) you can also look at it like the walking is imperfect because it set the scene and then the saltó is preterite because it interrupted it, bien hecho :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
It is good. Could have done without the subject pronoun, but it certainly works! - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
In context you probably wouldn't need the pronoun but just as a lone sentence it helps :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
oh! thanks guys! - hazyrra, Sep 17, 2010
1
vote

Given:

When i was singing in my room, my father switch off the light.

Translated:

Original: grammatically correct but awkward:

Cuando yo estaba cantando en mi cuarto, mi papá apagó la luz.

Suggested: Cantaba en mi cuarto cuando papá apagó la luz

Reason:

was singing - imperfect, sets the scene

turned off - preterite, interrupting action

yo - needed because it could be I, he, she etc

New Sentence:

Did you enjoy the way that the dancers jumped so high? I liked the bit where they did cartwheels.

updated Sep 17, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Shouldn't it be "switched"? - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
Your sentence is ok, but sounds awkward in Spanish. Actually, sounds a bit awkward in English, too! This is one case where a more liberal interpretation may be helpful: - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
"Cantaba en mi cuarto cuando papá apagó la luz". - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
oh my goodness now we're needing English lessons! that has to be a backwards step lol. That's what you call cutting and pasting without awareness lol :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
ok gracias I like to know how it would be said as much as how it should :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
1
vote

Given: I felt terrible when I realized that the children didn't ever have a chance to survive.

Transalation: Me sentí muy mal cuando me di cuenta de que nunca los niños tuvieron la opurtunidad de sobrevivir.

Reason: - sentía - Imperfect emotional state - me di cuenta de - Preterite a completed action - tuvieron - Preterite

New Sentence: Last night our air conditioner stopped working. So, we went out and bought two portable air conditioners and installed them before we went to bed.

updated Sep 17, 2010
edited by MrFreeze1125
posted by MrFreeze1125
would it be los niños nunca tuvieron la oportunidad? and a little typo with sobrevivir :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
Me sentí muy mal cuando comprendí que los niños nunca tuvieron la posibilidad de sobrevivir. You correctly translated both in Preterite, although you said the first part is imperfect. - Gekkosan, Sep 17, 2010
1
vote

Given: Last night our air conditioner stopped working. So, we went out and bought two portable air conditioners and installed them before we went to bed.

Translation: Original: Anoche, nuestro acondiciondor de aire acabó de funcionar. Así, salíamos y comprábamos dos acondicionadores de aire portátiles y los instalamos antes que nos acostamos.

Corrected Version: Anoche, nuestro acondiciondor de aire se descompuso (rompió, paró), así que salimos y compramos dos acondicionadores de aire portátiles y los instalamos antes de acostarnos.

Reason: acabó de- the preterite is used because the air conditioner stopped working at a specific moment in the past (last night).

salíamos - the imperfect is used because we didn't go out at a specified time.

comprábamos - same reason; exactly when they bought the appliances is unknown

instalamos - the preterite is used because they installed the appliances before they went to bed (specific time in the past)

acostamos - the preterite is also used here because they are going to sleep that night.

Necesito ayuda porque creo que hay errores en la traducción.

New Sentence: I was walking down the street when a woman jumped from behind a bush.

updated Sep 17, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by BajolaSombra
i think should be - fuimos a comprar.. preterite bcause it was occur and ended at tht time. - hazyrra, Sep 17, 2010
Anoche, nuestro acondiciondor de aire se descompuso (rompió, paró), así que salimos y compramos dos acondicionadores de aire portátiles y los instalamos antes de acostarnos. This should be all preterite. "Acabó de funcionar" in not the way we'd say it. - 00e657d4, Sep 17, 2010
thanx G :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
Kudos to you Bajola that Mr Freeze always seems to leave a doozy of a sentence :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 17, 2010
1
vote

The teacher taught the children how to do algebra but they couldn't remember the technique.

El profesor les enseñó a los niños cómo hacer álgebra, pero ellos no pudieron recordar la técnica.

==Past Perfect for single actions in the past

New sentence:

Their neighbor was very curious; whenever he climbed up the near hill and got a good view, he spied on them.

updated Sep 14, 2010
edited by luz_72
posted by luz_72
"El profesor les enseño a los niños cómo hacer álgebra". The last parat is ambiguous. It could be "No podían recordar" or "no pudieron recordar", depending on context. Given that sentence, and no choice, I'd have gone for "pudieron":. - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
Estoy de acuerdo :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 14, 2010
Thanks Gekko and Maria...:) - luz_72, Sep 14, 2010
1
vote

Given:

I practiced Spanish for the first time this weekend with a new friend using Skype. (I did not do very well but he was very patient with me.)

Translated:

Practiqué español por primera vez este fin de semana con un nuevo amigo a través de Skype. (No lo hice muy bien, pero él fue muy paciente conmigo.)

Reasons:

Practiqué - preterite, completed specific action

no lo hice - preterite, referring to the specific action as above

fue - preterite, (?? sorry Gek I still don't really get it, I thought the imperfect was used to describe characteristics - maybe the penny will drop on it for me later.)

(I put the personal pronoun so that you wouldn't have to wait until the 'conmigo' to see that I was talking about the friend - would that be right or not necessary?)

New Sentence:

The weather was very sunny but the people weren't expecting it so they got sunburnt.

updated Sep 14, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
We were doing fine until the evil "ser & estar" struck again. Want to try again? :-) - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
can't I have 'estar' / 'estaba' if he isn't usually patient but this weekend he happened to be? :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 14, 2010
THe way it`s written it *must* be "fue paciente conmigo". If you want to use "estar" you'd have to say: "pero (ese día) él estuvo muy paciente conmigo" - Gekkosan, Sep 14, 2010
ok ok I bow the the sensei :( - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 14, 2010
1
vote

I thought that I saw my friend in the crowd today but then I remembered that she went to the other side of town when the market was on, so it couldn't be her

Pensé que vi a mi amiga en la multitud hoy, pero entonces me acordé de que ella se fue al otro lado de la ciudad, cuando se abrió el mercado, así que no podía ser ella.

==Preterite for single events in the past and "podía ser" I don't really know why, it sounded good to me...

New sentence:

It was a complicated sentence, but I translated it the best I could.

updated Sep 14, 2010
edited by luz_72
posted by luz_72
wouldn't that be 'had seen' Luz? would 'vi' work? And woudn't abrió be more like the act of 'opening'? I'm not sure what would be usual to say there though - can correr be used like on when it comes to events? or is pasar better? Thoughts anyone? :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 3, 2010
...yes, "vi" is more accurate, thanks Maria:)...not sure for "market was on"...I thought maybe "estaba abierto"... - luz_72, Sep 4, 2010
yes, that sounds good :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 11, 2010
I don't really understand the English sentence. What does it mean "she wento to the other side...when the market was on"?? This sounds like something I might put in the imperfect, maybe.... - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
I agree, it means that whenever the market was running on the other side of town that's where she would go - so definitely the imperfect but how do you say that in Spanish? we use 'it was on' meaning running/going etc. - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 14, 2010
But wouldn't the use of "whenever" be required here to indicate a recurring action? - Gekkosan, Sep 14, 2010
1
vote

Given:

I used to go to class every Monday from four to six p.m.

Translated:

Iba a la clase todos los lunes de 4pm a 6pm.

Reason:

iba - imperfect; even though a specific day and time is described I used the imperfect because it's the 'going' that he used to do - which is different than saying 'I went on Monday from 4 to 6pm. I could also have put 'solía ir' - used to go.

New sentence:

We were going to eat after the movie but no one had an appetite so we just had a drink.

updated Sep 14, 2010
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Yeah, I'd have preferred the "solía ir"; I think. It's fine, though. - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
Is it just me or is "solía" something that doesn't come out much in spoken language? I lived in Guatemala for two years and didn't hear it ever. - ambie18, Sep 13, 2010
THere are regional variations, and also cultural variations that influence the usage of certain words. Generally speaking, yes you'll probably find more instances of this word in written rather than in spoken Spanish. - Gekkosan, Sep 14, 2010
1
vote

Given: I was going to go to the shops but in the end I decided to kayak over to a small island and have a picnic.

Translated: Iba a ir a las tiendas, pero al final decidí ir a una islita en kayak y hacer un picnic.

Reason: iba/ir - is imperfect because it was an ongoing action. decidí/decidir - is preterite because it was one time event.

New: I practiced Spanish for the first time this weekend with a new friend using Skype. (I did not do very well but he was very patient with me.)

updated Sep 14, 2010
edited by MrFreeze1125
posted by MrFreeze1125
gr8 try Mr Freeze :) - one little thing I would say is that the original says 'have a picnic' but you have 'had a picnic' perhaps you could think of how to change that? If not I'm sure our erstwhile moderator will be along presently to help us all out:) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 7, 2010
I was very unsure about everything after decidí. - MrFreeze1125, Sep 7, 2010
"Erstwhile" indeed! The cheek! . Remember Mr.Freeze - avoid subject pronouns as a general rule. - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
"Iba a ir a las tiendas, pero al final decidí ir a una islita en kayak y hacer un picnic". Imperfect first, then preterite. - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010
Gracias, Gekkosan. - MrFreeze1125, Sep 14, 2010
1
vote

Given: I figured out which soccer field my son's practice was on this afternoon just in time.

Translated: Justo a tiempo me di cuenta en qué campo de fútbol sería la práctica de mi hijo esta tarde.

Reason:

di - preterite, singular completed actions (figured out/realized)

sería: conditional - although the English uses the word 'was' which sounds like the past I felt that the conditional worked better, not sure why so likely I'm way off lol smile

New Sentence:

I was winning the game when the lights went out.

updated Sep 14, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
"en qué". Your version is fine, although I might say: "en cuál cancha de fútbol era la práctica de mi hijo" - Gekkosan, Sep 13, 2010