Home
Q&A
G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

G A M E - Preterite vs Imperfect

61
votes

Objective: practice in the use of the past tenses, preterite & imperfect

The rules:-----------------------------

  1. translate the English sentence given by the person above into Spanish using the correct preterite or imperfect verb conjugations

make sure you click on N E W E S T before you begin

Then

  1. state whether you used the preterite or the imperfect and give a short explanation as to why you used it

  • and finally
  1. provide a new sentence in English which includes a verb used in the past

for the next person to translate.

Have fun! ¡Diviértanse!

A suggestion: please keep your sentences simple. This is tricky stuff, so let's concentrate on the tenses, ok? - Gekko.

PS: here's a great link showing how the preterite is for action in the past whereas the imperfect is an ongoing condition in the past: Imperfecto vs Preterito and another that I've put together that may be of some use too, Pret vs Imp.

A big thanks to Gekko who 'was' kindly correcting this thread - Gekko if you have a mo' please post a thread below introducing yourself or post empty thread for me to introduce you, thus allowing the grateful participants to vote for all your hard and much appreciated work here wink

Edit - Sadly Gekko doesn't come round much anymore :( we'd love it if he did but in the meantime any corrections or suggestions are gratefully accepted and if someone would like to volunteer to help with moderation of this game, that'd be awesome, please just let us know so we can welcome you officially to the possie (as us antipodeans say (ie. position))

alt text

105508 views
updated Oct 25, 2014
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Maria Claire, this is a great idea! I wish you lots of takers - 005faa61, Aug 10, 2010
Muchisimas gracias :) thanx for joining in! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 10, 2010
So many views and so few posts? Come on guys just have a go - this is for learning and we're all here to help and be helped so have a crack :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Great idea Marie-Claire :) - --Jen--, Aug 11, 2010
What a "perfect" game!!! - --Mariana--, Aug 11, 2010
Muchisimas gracias a Maria, necesito mucha practica en el preterito/el imperfecto! - schemmn, Aug 11, 2010
Why I have seen this before my quiz last night?? Oh, well final exam is tomorrow and it will be on that, too! Muchas gracias! - chica_rica, Aug 11, 2010
Great game Maria!! I think I fixed all my mistakes! Thanks to Gekko for all his help. :) - Jason7R, Aug 11, 2010
Ok peeps, I don't know about you all but I feel like my understanding of the preterite and imperfect has improved out of sight in the just the last couple of days and I'd love to do similar threads with other things - por vs para, present vs subjunctive - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
etc, so I'm begging for moderators, please, pretty please. If out of the goodness of your heart you would consider volunteering please PM me, I know many of us would be sooooo grateful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Wonderful game MC and thanks to Gekkosan for all his help!!! - Izanoni1, Aug 18, 2010
I know, he's the bomb isn't he lol :) but don't tell him it'll probably go to his head je je Glad you're enjoying the game :) I've learnt heaps so far! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 18, 2010
Well done Maria, I never thought you'd get 100 answers for this. - fontanero, Aug 19, 2010
I think we all need so much help with it - have you joined in yet? Come on, give it a go, we're all getting heaps wrong, it's the best way to learn so don't be shy :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 19, 2010
Thank you Marie for you encouragement and to Gekkosan for patiently answering all my questions - sanlee, Aug 21, 2010
You're welcome :) My thanx too to Gekko, he's been very patient with us all and very, very helpful :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 25, 2010
wonderful game, marie, thanks gekko too:) - 00494d19, Sep 1, 2010
Thanx Heidita,getting the idea was pretty easy but thanks to Gekko who's doing most of the hard work ;) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 2, 2010

388 Answers

1
vote

I was winning the game when the lights went out.

Ganaba el juego cuando se apagaron las luces.

Ganaba= imperfect b/c it has no definite start and is an action that was happening when it was interrupted by another action.

Apagaron (also, it's a passive/unexpected event)= preterite because it is a one-time action with a distinct start and end and interrupts another event.

New sentence: I used to go to class every Monday from four to six p.m.

updated Sep 13, 2010
edited by la-maestra-roja
posted by la-maestra-roja
You seem to have a double up there La Maestra with your 'se apagaron' - or you could use 'se cortó' for 'went out' instead of were 'turned off' :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 11, 2010
1
vote

Sentence Given:
I realized that, in fact, I have only spent eleven days on the river since I moved here.
"Me di cuenta de que, en realidad, solamente he pasado once días en el río desde que me mudé aquí. I used the perfect tense because it appears that there is no clear timeframe of when this event occurred as well as there is no "interrupting" past tense phrase. (took a shot at an explanation). smile
New Sentence:
I figured out which soccer field my son's practice was on this afternoon just in time.

updated Sep 13, 2010
edited by Jason7R
posted by Jason7R
I have only spent => solamente he pasado. This is present perfect. "Me di cuenta de que, en realidad, solamente he pasado once días en el río desde que me mudé aquí. The preterit would also fit, although it would not be literal. - 00e657d4, Sep 10, 2010
So should I change it or is this acceptable? I just want to do it the right way!! :) - Jason7R, Sep 11, 2010
1
vote

I used to be very happy when my daughter was only interested in toys; lately I realized she became interested in boys too.

Yo era muy contento cuando mi hija se era interesado sólo juguetes. Recientemente ya supe que ella se volvía interesado en chicos también.

Lots of reflexive going on. I'm sure I made a lot of mistakes :( Any corrections welcome.

New Sentence:

I used to hate going to school when I was a teenager, but now I am glad that I went to college.

updated Sep 10, 2010
posted by spgeise
estaba interesado en juguetes. I would darse cuenta, The pretrite of saber means to find out something. - BellaMargarita, Aug 19, 2010
"ser & estar" strikes hard here: Yo era muy feliz cuando mi hija se interesaba sólo por juguetes; ¡recientemente me he dado cuenta de que también se ha interesado en chicos! - Gekkosan, Aug 19, 2010
1
vote

Given sentence I used to mind being interrupted when I work, but then I learnt how to ignore them.

As recommended by Gekkosan, a more natural translation is: Antes me molestaba que me interrumpieran mientras trabajo, pero luego aprendí a ignorarlo.

Imperfect because past action done repeatedly second preterit because luego gives a time. However, you can't mark the date on the calendar, but the action is complete. So I will to with past tense events that occur into the present.

New Sentence When I was young, my father was in the Navy. We moved over twenty times. My parents left kids on each coast after they graduated from high school.

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
Yay, Marie. Historic !100 answers to your post. You rock!!! - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
Very good. "Aprender" should go in the preterite, though. - Gekkosan, Aug 19, 2010
Don't you think she learned as she went along, not all of the sudden one day? - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
I think the word 'then' stresses the beginning of something new and a fairly sudden change in state or condition takes the preterite. :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 19, 2010
That would tell me that one day she just, boing, magically learned to ignore them. Is that what happened? - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
Although "luego" is not a concrete time, it nevertheless signifies that at some point she stopped being bothered , and started coping. One action ended, and another started. - Gekkosan, Aug 19, 2010
So even though an action lasted a long time, if it stopped and changed then it is preterit??? - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
you've got it! :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 19, 2010
Not really, but I guess I have to take it on faith, eh? - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
There, I changed it. - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
Well, is it right or not?? - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
The handling of the tenses is perfect. A more natural translation would be: Antes me molestaba que me interrumpieran mientras trabajo, pero luego aprendí a ignorarlo" - Gekkosan, Aug 19, 2010
Okay, then. Gracias, Gekkosan - sanlee, Aug 20, 2010
Gekkosan, I believe the reason for the preterit is past tense events occurring into the present. - sanlee, Aug 21, 2010
1
vote

please delete my duplicate post

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by revmaf
posted by revmaf
1
vote

Sentence Given:
We went to the beach.

Fuimos a la playa.

Preterite = action in the past

It was hot outside today.

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Jason7R
I don't know? I would use íbamos for 'we used to go' to the beach but the given sentence sounds like an action to me - so I would use 'fuimos'. Let's see what the pro's say lol :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 17, 2010
I guess my thoguht was that there was no definite timeframe, "When did they go to the beach?" We went to the beach..."an hour ago, a day ago, or a week ago.." Help! :) - Jason7R, Aug 17, 2010
Sorry Bubba. I agree with the Woman from the Sea here. "fuimos" is the correct option. In English "We went" means we did it only once. If it were a regular activity, it'd be "used to go". - Gekkosan, Aug 17, 2010
It's really helped me to think of 'actions' in the past as needing the preterite, rather than thinking in time frames - have a look at the link I've put up in the original post Jason and let me know if it helps :) Hope you don't mind but I changed your - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 17, 2010
post to avoid confusion :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 17, 2010
I will check it out Marie. I swear I was going with fuimos and changed my mind! Crud! :) - Jason7R, Aug 17, 2010
lol I know that, don't you hate that ja ja - go with your gut! - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 17, 2010
Jason, just go to the beach. Just do it, - sanlee, Aug 19, 2010
1
vote

Is there a new sentence for translation?

updated Sep 10, 2010
posted by --Mariana--
Yes, mine, "It was hot outside today." - Jason7R, Aug 17, 2010
And mine as well. - sanlee, Aug 17, 2010
je je :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 17, 2010
1
vote

How did work go? Did you get everything that you wanted to?

¿Cómo fue el trabajo más? ¿Recibiste todas las cosas que quisieras?

Preterite: the sentence indicates a past incident.

New sentence: what did you do when John arrived?

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by Ashis
posted by Ashis
The sentence was difficult for my level. I just wanted to attempt it. Please correct my errors. - Ashis, Aug 16, 2010
It was a gr8 try Ashis, just one little thing is the sentence given said, "did you get everything done that you wanted to' which will mean you will need different verbs :( Do you feel like having another go? - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 16, 2010
Ashis, I will wait along with María to give you a chance to give it another try. You made a good attempt, but particularly in the second part, you have the meanings wrong. - Gekkosan, Aug 16, 2010
1
vote

The tie he tried on was very expensive.

La corbata que se probó era muy cara.

probó preterit: single completed action. era imperfect: describes a characteristic.


New: After returning from a trip while waiting at the airport it was there that I first met the woman of my dreams.

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by MattM
posted by MattM
Whew...I almost said "fue muy caro". - MattM, Aug 14, 2010
lol, you were so worried about doing it it looks like you did - I think it would be imperfect 'era' for characteristics - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 14, 2010
Correct, María: "era muy cara". - Gekkosan, Aug 14, 2010
True story, Matt? - sagiia, Aug 15, 2010
lol - good question sagiia :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 15, 2010
Era it is. Thank you all. No I made this one up. True story is I met her in a bar. - MattM, Aug 16, 2010
1
vote

¿Recuerdas al hombre que se llamaba Pablo y quien llevaba anteojos? Pues, se enfermó y casi se murió.

WAS called and WORE = imp, because they are background info, description, etc. GOT sick and DIED = 1 time Completed Past Actions.

New sentence: During the Inquisition, Isabel and Ferdinand were feared by many of theri subjects.

updated Sep 10, 2010
posted by madrededos
remember to hit the 'newest' tab before you begin :) you seem to have picked up an old sentence :( instead of Jason's - "People didn't believe me ......you can't take money with you. Perhaps you might like to try that one :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 12, 2010
1
vote

Maria's other Old Sentence: (I need help!!) wink
Mary tried to buy the house but John didn't want her to buy it.
Mary intentó de comprar la casa, pero John no le quería comprarlo.
Past for the first part of the sentence and imperfect for the second part of the sentence. (1st--already happened, 2nd--undetermine amount of time that John didn't want to buy the house---probably forever!!) smile
New Sentence #2:
I bought a house 4 years ago and have fixed it up. (true story)

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by Jason7R
posted by Jason7R
good try, the quería (imp) is correct because that was an ongoing action but the 'intentabas' (imp) wouldn't be correct because she tried, it's a completed action :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Crud!!! ;) I'll change it to the past tense of intentar...gracias amiga!! - Jason7R, Aug 11, 2010
Is it wrong the way I wrote it? Or is it an akward way of saying this? I want to learn!!! - Jason7R, Aug 11, 2010
ja ja - that's all good, no one can learn without making mistakes - I would put: María intentó de comprar la casa, pero John no quería que se lo compre. (but just wait someone will probably come along and teach me ja ja) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
intentaste is the tú form in the preterite so you would be saying 'you bought' rather than 'she or Maria bought' - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
What was I thinking?? Oh yeah, I wasn't!! ;) - Jason7R, Aug 12, 2010
María is close, but not quite there in her correction. This is an awkward sentence in Spanish; a better literal version would be: "Mary intentó comprar la casa, pero John no quería que lo hiciera".... - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
However, I'd favor an interpreted version along the lines: "María intentó comprar la casa, aunque John no estaba de acuerdo". - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
I think that the declaration of "preterite" or "imperfect" ought to be in the post, where people can see it, hm? - Gekkosan, Aug 12, 2010
Oops, I thought I had put it in there...I did fix the others awhile back. :) - Jason7R, Aug 12, 2010
1
vote

La viajeta sentaba meciéndose junto al fuego, cuando de repente, eschuchó que golpeaban fuertemente la puerta.

Imperfect was used for sentaba because the woman was doing something and then preterite for eschuchó because the knock interrupted what she was doing.

New sentence. I was driving home and it began to rain.

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by MrFreeze1125
posted by MrFreeze1125
Sentaba is imperfect so imperfect tense first. (The imperfect tense sets the scene,) then preterite: se fue interrupts the activity - FELIZ77, Aug 11, 2010
Muchas gracias. - MrFreeze1125, Aug 11, 2010
There are a couple of errors in your otherwise nice translation. Here's a corrected version: " La viejita (sounds nicer than "vieja") estaba sentada meciéndose junto al fuego, cuando de repente, escuchó que golpeaban fuertemente la puerta." - Gekkosan, Aug 11, 2010
Nice to have you join in Mr Freeze, please correct your post, as per Gekko's corrections :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
Thanks Gekkosan and Maria-Claire. I didn't notice the sentence was edited before I submitted my translation. - MrFreeze1125, Aug 11, 2010
Please explain meciéndose to me. - MrFreeze1125, Aug 11, 2010
I think I understand meciendose now. Mecerse is a reflexing verb. The old woman was rocking herself in the chair. - MrFreeze1125, Aug 11, 2010
that's it - reflexive :) doing it to herself, bien hecho :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 11, 2010
1
vote

Given:

They were deadly exhausted and tried to evade it but it was too late and the boat stranded.

Translated:

Estaban mortalmente agotados y trataron de evadirlo, pero era demasiado tarde, y el barco encalló.

Reasons:

estaban atogados - estar in the imperfect to describe conditions in the past

trataron - preterite single completed action

era demasiado tarde - ser in the imperfect to describe time in the past

encalló - stranded, single completed action

New sentence:

I used up the last of the milk, where do you usually buy it?

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Tsk-tsk... definitely ser& estar is by far the deadlier enemy. :-/ English speakers really have no mental frame reference for this! - Gekkosan, Sep 1, 2010
"Estaban mortalmente agotados y trataron de evadirlo, pero era demasiado tarde, y el barco encalló". - Gekkosan, Sep 1, 2010
right you are! gracias :) - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 2, 2010
thanks for the new word too, I've never come across 'encallar' - I don't think we can really say 'the boat stranded' in English so it threw me a bit. I think we'd have to say 'became stranded' or some similar construction. - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 2, 2010
I thought so, but since I'm not that much of a sailor, I figured I'd better not risk it. :-) - Gekkosan, Sep 8, 2010
lol :) Welcome back! - Kiwi-Girl, Sep 8, 2010
1
vote

There were dark clouds and the wind blew last night so we thought that we were going to get a storm.

Había unas nubes negras y el viento soplaba anoche, así que pensamos que ibamos a tener una tormenta.

==Imperfect for a description in the past and Preterite for single actions in the past

New sentence:

The area seemed deserted and unhabited, but they kept on walking and came across a small cottage.

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by luz_72
posted by luz_72
Ok, you have to actions taking place simultaneously: the existence of the black clouds, and the wind blowing. So they should be in the same tense! What's it's going to be? :-) - Gekkosan, Aug 28, 2010
I would say Imperfect, because of the "description" thing... - luz_72, Aug 29, 2010
That is correct. So how yould you write the whole thing, then? - Gekkosan, Aug 29, 2010
Espero que sea correcto ahora:)...Gracias, Gekko:) - luz_72, Aug 29, 2010
1
vote

I thought I understood how the preterite and imperfect tenses worked, but apparently, I was wrong!

¡Pensé que comprendía cómo los tiempos de pretérito e imperfecto pero aparentemente me equivoqué.

Pensé, and equivoqué are preterit - completed past action, comprendía, is imperfect because ongoing. The thinking and being wrong are in the past and completed, but the understanding is on going past action

I thought all this practice would help, but tell me when will we figure this out?

updated Sep 10, 2010
edited by sanlee
posted by sanlee
Alright, I admit it. I have no idea if it would be estar or ser in I was wrong. Can you give me a hint? - sanlee, Aug 27, 2010
Sandy I would put pensar in the imperfect because it's an ongoing opinion but comprender I would put in the preterite as a completed action. Actually that's quite a tricky sentence, perhaps funcionar is a better verb than trabajar for that kind of worked - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 28, 2010
but let's see what Gekko says :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 28, 2010
I had those tense at first then I changed them because one day. I was so confused. - sanlee, Aug 28, 2010
Yo pensaba que comprendía cómo los tiempos de pretérito e imperfecto funcionan, pero aparentemente, no tuve razón! - sanlee, Aug 28, 2010
imperfect for describing mental/emotional states or desires in the past. But I still think that it could be preterit. It is in the past and it is over. - sanlee, Aug 28, 2010
I am beginning to think we should ask Lazarus to provide a tutorial based on these excercises and the answers provided. The fact is, Sanlee, that your original sentence is nearly correct. - Gekkosan, Aug 28, 2010
Pensé que comprendía cómo funcionan los tiempos de pretérito e imperfecto, pero aparentemente me equivoqué. - Gekkosan, Aug 28, 2010
Ok, great! Gracias, Gekkosa. Are my reasons correct completed action fpr pensar and comprender and on going action for wrong? - sanlee, Aug 28, 2010
Are they all preterit? - sanlee, Aug 28, 2010
Pensé and equivoqué are preterite. Comprendía is imperfect. - Gekkosan, Aug 28, 2010
If the thinking sets the scene or is an ongoing opinion wouldn't it be in the imperfect? Contrasted with a thought that just pops into your head which would need the preterite But what would I know lol :) - Kiwi-Girl, Aug 29, 2010
The thinking and being wrong are in the past and completed, but the understanding is on going past action? Is that how it is, Gekkoan?? - sanlee, Aug 29, 2010
Essentially, yes. - Gekkosan, Aug 29, 2010