Home
Q&A
SpanishDict forum is closing down on the 17th of October

SpanishDict forum is closing down on the 17th of October

13
votes

Please look at the top of the page:

SpanishDict forum is closing down on the 17th of October.

In case you are interested, this is the forum we came from. if you want to join us there, feel free to come along.

If many people come, the forum might get a new start.

We used to have the same sections as here, Word of the Day, daily threads in general, The International Café...

Spanish Help Community Forum

4350 views
updated Oct 16, 2017
edited by 00fac92a
posted by 006595c6
Just as I got going again! So off we go back to Spanish Help Community Forum, which actually is quite a nice place - but needs people!!! - caza, Oct 12, 2017
I have just checked in. I have a feeling of deja vu - porcupine7, Oct 12, 2017

36 Answers

15
votes

SD will die without the Forum.

It was the only place where members could interact - give advice and express opinions - good or bad.

Mods did a good job in controlling any divisive chatter especially about politics and religion.

Closing it is nothing but an idea to prevent any real interaction among members.

SD will become just what its name suggests a SpanishDictionary. with bits added on.

IMO opinion it is a reduction of free speech.

updated Oct 15, 2017
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
What I will not forgive is the closure of my beautiful café...such a nonsensical thing to do, after all closing the forum was not decided yesterday! - 006595c6, Oct 11, 2017
Nope it wasn't it was an attempt to get control of all opinion expressed on SD and now on SD as a whole. - What ever happened to "free speech" is it now dead? - ian-hill, Oct 11, 2017
We will follow you to the other place, Heidi :) - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
I agree that Spanishdict is now as good as dead. Adios, amigos. It's been a real pleasure knowing you. - AnnRon, Oct 11, 2017
Ian, You and Ray have my Facebook address, so we can still stay in touch. - Daniela2041, Oct 12, 2017
Just as I got going again! So off we go back to Spanish Help Community Forum, which actually is quite a nice place - but needs people!!! - caza, Oct 12, 2017
Thanks for a job well done. I will miss you guys; ( - Ranman, Oct 12, 2017
13
votes

I haven't been here as long as some of you, but this has been my Spanish home for the last four years; and the forum has been the kitchen, the place where all the most important activities of the Spanishdict family take place, the place where guests gather and everyone feels comfortable and chummy. I feel as if robbers have broken into my house, stolen everything of value, and set fire to what was left. The owners have gutted their own site. Right now I don't have the will to explore a new-to-me website—maybe after a few days when the smoke has cleared. Anyway, if it happens that I don't catch up with the rest of you, it's been a blast.

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by AnnRon
On the contrary, for the first time in my life I did what I was given advice to do and moved immediately there, and, you know? it feels good. I know I was not settled here yet, but I still hate changes ... I'm going there in case there's some question... - aleCcowaN, Oct 12, 2017
:) - ian-hill, Oct 12, 2017
I sure hope you will come to SH, Ann. I understand exactly how you feel, but I want you to know, we would love to have you there. I don't want to lose touch with you, amiga. It's a great place and I think you'll be happy there with us. ♥ - rac1, Oct 12, 2017
13
votes

This has come as a shock to me and the other moderators. It's so sad, like a bad dream. We loved it here. We've been here a long time and now it has come to an end. I'm just so, so sad. I'm sorry everyone that this happened. I wish there was something we could do about it, but there isn't. I love you all...

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by rac1
We love you all too, Amber Thank you all for serving us so faithfully and kindly volver the years! - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
I hate to say it, but "I told you so " ...more than once, don't get too attached, it happend to me it can happen to you. and now it did happen, to all of us - 006595c6, Oct 11, 2017
A real shocj Amber - and not really necessary. - ian-hill, Oct 11, 2017
lest's go there - polenta1, Oct 11, 2017
Bye Sis. Thanks for being my friend. You guy did an amazing job. I'll miss you: ( - Ranman, Oct 12, 2017
Thank you, Bro. I sure wish you would come with us. Remember, the door id always open. I will dearly miss you too. :( - rac1, Oct 13, 2017
12
votes

*Hi Ifeel I am standing outside the divorce court with a hole in my pocket and no home ,all I wanted was my old dog. If anymembers want to keep in touch P M me.I am very sad and a bit pissed**

updated Oct 13, 2017
posted by ray76
A bit Ray! Mate, I'm gutted and have invested only a fraction of what you have into this site. I've been awaiting your 400K celebration and instead we get this. It's like blowing a party horn that has had the whistle removed and the end cut off. - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
:) - ian-hill, Oct 11, 2017
hi ray, I am with you on this, I have you on skype, so we will be in contact - 006595c6, Oct 12, 2017
I will miss you Mate. I'm going to Mexico City in Nov. and England in Feb. Maybe our paths will cross. Thanks for being a Rock Star in the forum. Boo to Spanishdict - Ranman, Oct 12, 2017
We may meet again mate I hope so . It has been a pleasure knowing you and wirking with you. - ray76, Oct 13, 2017
11
votes

I guess I'll see you guys over there. ¡Qué lástima!

? ?

Dani.

updated Oct 14, 2017
edited by Daniela2041
posted by Daniela2041
Yep, me too, Dani. - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
Bueno, no entiendo de foros pero una vez que me metí en uno, cierra. - polenta1, Oct 11, 2017
Dani, I hope you know where it is, amiga??? - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
Hola bonita - thanks for trying as you did xx - ian-hill, Oct 11, 2017
I'm going to give it another "go" when I get home from work around 7pm California time. - Daniela2041, Oct 11, 2017
I haven't been as active here lately (using Fluencia), but I've had SD always open in one of my tabs on my PC. Guess I'll mosey on over to the other place (and will still stay Findy). - Findy, Oct 13, 2017
11
votes

Well, everyone else is being understanding, which is good I guess, but somebody has to come out and say it: Typical corporate decision. Cut off the loose ends because they are too troublesome and not making enough money.

I wonder if any thought was put in to the SD community itself, which is effectively being euthanised. We are real people here SD, not automatons. Many of us have invested a lot of time, thought, and effort into this forum. But all of that counts for nought apparently, when bottom-lines are the primary concern.

Gutted as I am, I can only imagine how devastated the regular contributors, and the Mods especially, must be, having invested at least 10 times the amount I ever have. I feel so sorry for you guys and the fact that SD has not fore-warned you of this development highlights their, or should I say its, corporate heartlessness.

And that is what SD will be without the forum. Another heartless husk of a site. So be it. This will probably be my last post. I'm hopping the fence and heading for the hills before they can take me behind the barn and do me in.

My thoughts to you all. See you on the other side, perhaps.

updated Oct 13, 2017
posted by jellonz
I hope so, amigo. - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
I saw you joined SpanishHelp, can you figure out how to use. I no longer know how to. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Hi jello, it was done to me before, in the very same way, so I am not surprised. however, I do understand, it is a business and it doesn't give them any money - 006595c6, Oct 11, 2017
I will miss you , jello :) - 006595c6, Oct 11, 2017
Not a clue Bosque. I'm wondering if there is a probation period that limits our access? - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
I have been there forever, obviously, and I cant find my mod function, so go figure, lol - 006595c6, Oct 11, 2017
I am using my old account. I am Royalty category and a member since 2012. I can do nothing. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Well, that's my theory crushed. I'll have a bit of a play around but at present I'm lost in the fog. - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
I'm not done yet Heidi :) I'll give SH my best shot, although I am a bit of a change-a-phobe. We'll see how it goes :) - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
I would hate to lose you. :) - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Cheers mate :) - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
11
votes

Ray and all my amigos.

SD have no idea about how we feel mates or just don't care.

Without the forum especially and the regular help and chat on that SD will not exist for long.

updated Oct 13, 2017
posted by ian-hill
I agree 1000%, Ian. Where do we send flowers? - DonBigoteDeLaLancha, Oct 11, 2017
I hope that one day they will wake up to the fact that what is worth saving cannot always be valued in numerical/financial terms I am not into any political system but capitalism stnks at times because all it values is money .what can show up on - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
profit and loss sheet rather than valuing human relationships! People before profit! :) - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
This forum was the heart of Spanishdict ...once again it has been ripped out! - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
I agree with Feliz and Ian. Money has always gotten in the way of authentic relationships. Perhaps money makes the world go around but it doesn't make for a nice world. I don't know what would. :( - Sassette, Oct 12, 2017
....so I don't have a "well, I understand why SD has to do this" mentallity. It's a terrible decison and I hope SD sinks. The humanity will be ripped from this site. - Sassette, Oct 12, 2017
11
votes

I have no idea what has been done to SpanishHelp, but:

Once I login, essentially nothing is available to me except the sandbox. If I logout then I can see the full forum but cannot post.

There are a few administrative areas I can see but not post on.

I don't even know what happened to my messages, or how to send one now.

Nice to see JelloNZ has joined.

But if nobody knows how to navigate it, it will be hard to retain members, much less get new ones-

I am going to go back and see if I can figure out how to see what I did post.

updated Oct 13, 2017
posted by bosquederoble
Information You are not authorized to read private messages. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Information Sorry but you are not permitted to use the search system. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
I got that too, amigo. Ask Guillermo. - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
Not going to work if no one can figure out how to work it. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Polenta has joined, and posted on the sandbox. So I assume she can't get anywhere else either? - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
I'm sure Guillermo and Gekko will know. - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
Are we allowed to do a thread here about how to navigate Spanish Help? - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
It's working for me. - Gekkosan, Oct 11, 2017
I had the same issue Bosque. Found Heidi's post re SD, but after registering can't seem to find it again. Learning curve perhaps :) - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
Donbigote has also added onto the sandbox. Seems the only place we can reach. Unless we are a Gecko. :) - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
:) - ian-hill, Oct 11, 2017
I had dipped in a few times in last few months the but was puzzled by not being able to search or look at messages. - Mardle, Oct 11, 2017
Can you get anywhere but the sandbox where you have just posted? - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
I've already posted there. No problem. https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/spanishhelp/help-with-proofreading-texts-for-a-crowdfunded-env-t11052.html - aleCcowaN, Oct 11, 2017
My response when I try to get to that link: Information You are not authorized to read this forum. Unless I log out, then I can see it but not post. :( - bosquederoble, Oct 12, 2017
I had to reset my password, maybe that's the problem. - caza, Oct 12, 2017
It's all fixed now amigos. - rac1, Oct 12, 2017
Indeed it works now.:) - bosquederoble, Oct 12, 2017
11
votes

Well well well, there you go! Round and round and round lol.

Unfortunately the problem with Spanishelp will be the same as the problem before .................. no newbies.

Newbies are the life blood of any forum. That's why I try to treat people with common courtesy and respect .... even if they seem to not give two hoots what I think. As I said in a thread earlier today, every now and again somebody comes along who turns out to be a valued member and good (virtual) friend.

Without newbies we might aswell be a facebook friends group of old back-slapping amigos. I will give Spanishelp a try but let's just hope it doesn't die a slow lingering death like before.

The king is dead (SD) .... long live the king (SH) smile

updated Oct 13, 2017
edited by billygoat
posted by billygoat
♥♥♥ - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
right you are. - billygoat, Oct 11, 2017
I agree, the new members and their "silly" questions are a big part of my learning. :) - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
me too mate. It was part of the quaintness (is that a word lol) of the SD forum (RIP) - billygoat, Oct 11, 2017
10
votes

I am shocked but not surprised that this forum is closing down! Sadly, the management team have not been able to come up with a practical and viable solution to protect us here from the almost continuous onslaught of spammers whose evil intent has been to paralyse this forum and prevent us from enjoying it!

The moderators: Ray, Amber and Ian have tried to continue to do a fantastic job against seemingly impossible odds!

I sincerely hope and pray that all our friends/everybody here who is serious about learning Spanish and English will join us there! smile

updated Oct 17, 2017
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
Thank you, Feliz. :( - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
You are very welcome, Amber :) - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
10
votes

It's a sad day. Not only are we losing the learning ability, and the fun from the Q&A section, but reading through all the comments I can see that many true friendships have been formed.

Maybe if we transfer to Spanish Help (when the present access problems have been sorted out) and everyone tries to introduce someone new it will flourish again.

Please keep me updated if anyone finds a new "home"

Thanks to the mods. and all the help given.

updated Oct 16, 2017
posted by caza
:) - ian-hill, Oct 12, 2017
:) - FELIZ77, Oct 12, 2017
It is sad amiga. - rac1, Oct 12, 2017
it is very sad :'( and it's happening tomorrow !! ! - Taska5100, Oct 16, 2017
10
votes

Jeez! I get busy at work, and look what happens! I knew I should have bought that lottery ticket!

In all seriousness, I am so sad to see the forum close. This is really the only part of SD I've used. I haven't done any of the lessons or things like that - maybe 1 or 2. The Q&A is where I learned the most. Interacting with real people. Being given real-life practical tips and hints.

Heck, there's even another New Orleans person here. Yes, Rac1, you really helped me feel welcome here with that N'Awlins hospitality I grew up with.

Dani, I have those mini-lessons you've posted here all saved in a little Daniela SD Spanish text book.

Ray, Ian, Feliz, Bosque... and EVERYONE ELSE (I just don't have time or small enough fingers to put all your names here. I've enjoyed interacting with each and every one of you.

I will get on Spanish Help, and I will try to send PMs to all my special friends, and I hope we keep in touch.

As much as one can "love" strictly internet acquaintances, I love you all.

Que les vaya bien! Winkfish

p.s.- There'll be a big pot of gumbo waiting for any of you who makes it to New Orleans!

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by Winkfish
:) - ian-hill, Oct 12, 2017
Muchas Gracias, Wink...igualmente amigo :) - FELIZ77, Oct 12, 2017
Thank you, amigo. - rac1, Oct 12, 2017
10
votes

I've been trying to change the permissions in SpanishHelp. Please understand that since we left that forum a totally new platform has been installed. It's pretty much like starting from scratch.


I think I have given access all new and existing users the required rights. Please don't be discouraged. This will be a learning experience to everybody, me included.


If you have time take another look and let me know if now you can see all the sub-forums.

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by 00fac92a
Yes Guillermo. I can see Heidi's SH post re SD now (before I could only see it when logged off). Cheers. - jellonz, Oct 11, 2017
I still do not have access, only the sandbox, but I do have pm's. I cannot figure out how to search for users. - bosquederoble, Oct 11, 2017
Thank you Guillermo :) - FELIZ77, Oct 11, 2017
What's your user there, Bosque? - 00fac92a, Oct 12, 2017
stadt. - bosquederoble, Oct 12, 2017
I think is fixed. - 00fac92a, Oct 12, 2017
10
votes

I'm thinking "Abraham, Martin, and John". I sure hate to see the QA go away, There are so many beautiful people here. The dictionary and QA are my favorite parts.

I didn't know about the other forum mentioned earlier in this thread, and I've been here since 2008, I'm going to check it out.

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by DonBigoteDeLaLancha
It's the same way I feel, Bigote....Do check out SpanishHelp. - rac1, Oct 11, 2017
I am checking it out. I don't see how it can replace this , though. - DonBigoteDeLaLancha, Oct 11, 2017
10
votes

I have dipped in occasionally but the format has altered and some of the permissions, but I am no techie.

updated Oct 14, 2017
posted by Mardle
I Sent you an email. Did you receive it? - Polenta, Oct 13, 2017