Home
Q&A
Pronoun & conjugation confusion

Pronoun & conjugation confusion

4
votes

Ive started to listen to a lot of latin music and realise I am going to have a lot of questions smile.

The first being in this phrase 'Diciendo que le hago falta en su cama'

I have just learnt hacer falta is similar or the same as necesitar, so hago falta is I need, as well I understand the phrase is translated to 'saying that he needs me in his bed' but why is the yo form 'hago' used when 'le' is the one who is needing? Why is this the case and not 'me hace falta'

Or have I got the translation wrong?

Thanks!

404 views
updated Sep 19, 2017
posted by Jads1403
welcome to the forum, :) - 006595c6, Sep 18, 2017

5 Answers

3
votes

Hacer falta is a difficult one.

Here is a previous answer which includes a very useful list of how hacer falta is conjugated prepared by a member who is excellent at Spanish grammar. In effect it does not translate the way you think.

Previous answer

Effectively it means:

She needs me in her bed.

updated Sep 20, 2017
posted by Mardle
3
votes

Welcome to the forum, jads.

'Diciendo que le hago falta en su cama'

He is saying that he needs me in his bed. You could however a clearer version:

He is saying that I am the one he needs in his bed-

Add the pronoun:

Dice que yo le hago falta en la cama.

he says the I am the one he needs in his bed.

You are right, this is it, however, the conjugation of hacer falta, is somewhat odd.

updated Sep 20, 2017
posted by 006595c6
2
votes

Yo te hago falta. The subject in Spanish Is yo..

In English if you traslate it into** need** the subject Is not I (yo). The subject Is you (te).

Yo le hago falta. He needs me.
Yo les hago falta. They need me.
Tú me haces falta. I need you.
Usted me hace falta. I need you.
Nosotros te hacemos falta. You need us.
Ellos nos hacen falta. We need them.
Etc. Yo le hago falta en su cama. He needs me in His bed.

updated Sep 20, 2017
posted by Polenta
2
votes

Ahh that makes more sense thank you both!

updated Sep 19, 2017
posted by Jads1403
1
vote

Aprender "gustarle a uno" resuelve todo. smile Es la misma construcción.

Me gusta el libro- Yo like the book.

Me hace falta el libro- I need the book.

Spanish is sooooo logical.

updated Sep 19, 2017
posted by DonBigoteDeLaLancha