Home
Q&A
Which of these sentences is correct?

Which of these sentences is correct?

0
votes

Cuando esté mayor, yo sea como tú.

or

Cuando esté mayor, yo seré como tú.

1599 views
updated May 18, 2008
posted by daniel4

8 Answers

0
votes

You're quite right, James. My suggestion was less a translation suggestion for the op and more a tangent to show the different direction in which the second subjunctive would take the sentence. I could have been clearer, granted.

Oh, that I might be like you when I get older.

updated May 18, 2008
posted by David-H
0
votes

I think that's grammatically correct, but it means something slightly different: When I'm older, I hope to be like you.

Actually, "I hope to be like you" would be "Espero ser como tú," and your version is more like "God grant that I am like you," although the basic meaning is the same.

updated May 16, 2008
posted by 00bacfba
0
votes

How about this one for fun:

Cuando sea mayor, que yo sea como tú.

updated May 15, 2008
posted by David-H
0
votes

Sorry, ana, this is not correct,

Go with the answer given by Dunia!!

updated May 14, 2008
posted by 00494d19
0
votes

You don't have to double the "r" of "seré"

updated May 14, 2008
posted by Dunia
0
votes

"Cuando sea mayor, seré como tú"

Cuando+Subjunctive (future).

updated May 14, 2008
posted by Dunia
0
votes

It sounds like you're trying to say: when I'm older, I'll be like you, therefore you want to go with the second one: "Cuando serre mayor, serre como tu". "este" refers to being somewhere e.g. "este en la casa" versus "serre" refers to state of being/being somehow e.g. "serre despierto", "soy menor o mayor de edad". Ser versus estar is tricky & unique to spanish. The only similar auxiliary can be found in french, but it's still different even there.

updated May 14, 2008
posted by andradawietzelyahoocom
0
votes

neither...

are you trying to say when I was older, I was like you?
if so it is, cuando era mayor, fui como tu

updated May 14, 2008
posted by Sam