Home
Q&A
Should I use imperfect subjunctive here?

Should I use imperfect subjunctive here?

5
votes

If I want to say "it was not something that I liked", should I say "no era algo que me gustara"?

I had assumed that this is an adjective clause and I should use the subjunctive, but I am not entirely sure.

Also, does this sound weird? Would it better just to say "no me gustó"?

Gracias!

455 views
updated Sep 1, 2017
posted by elefantita

6 Answers

4
votes

"Gustara" is perfect in this context, because I assume you are not trying to say that there is something you liked, so subjunctive makes perfect sense, and the sentence sounds very natural.

Using indicative instead ("gustaba") would imply that apart of saying that you didn't like that thing, there is actually another one that you do actually like ("algo que me gustaba" = "me gustaba algo"), and you want others to know that, hence indicative. With subjunctive, you are not providing any information on whether there is something else you like instead or not; you are just commenting on your dislike for this thing with subjunctive, whereas in indicative, you are stating that you do like something, but obviously not the object mentioned in the main sentence, since it is a negative one. Both options are correct.

updated Sep 1, 2017
posted by lazarus1907
Muchas gracias. - rac1, Aug 15, 2017
Www, Thank you for your explanation, Lazarus ...I had not understood all the implications or nuances involved in using the indicative:) - FELIZ77, Aug 15, 2017
4
votes

As a Spanish learner too (so I could be wrong here) I would just simply say....

no me gustó.

updated Sep 1, 2017
posted by billygoat
3
votes

I agree with shameless, perfect choice , elefantita. Good job smile

updated Sep 1, 2017
posted by 006595c6
3
votes

no era algo que me gustara

Actually this is perfectly acceptable! It is correct to use subjunctive there and you need the imperfect because your "ruling" verb is in the past. Therefore: "no es algo que me guste" is okay, "no era algo que me gustara" is okay as well.

Of course, "no me gustaba" as Feliz mentioned, is okay as well. I would say that "no me gustó" is a little bit different, much more specific.

updated Sep 1, 2017
edited by Shamelesspanish
posted by Shamelesspanish
2
votes

No era algo que a mí me gustara is ok.

Many people are not using the past subjunctive but it seems it's incorrect. Who knows, within some decades it will become acceptable to use the present subjunctive.

updated Sep 1, 2017
posted by polenta1
2
votes

Hello Elefantina,

Welcome to our Spanishdict community forum smile

You asked:

Should I use imperfect subjunctive here? If I want to say "it was not something that I liked", should I say "no era algo que me gustara"? I had assumed that this is an adjective clause and I should use the subjunctive, but I am not entirely sure. Also, does this sound weird? Would it better just to say "no me gustó"?Gracias!

I like Billy's answer which is correct in itself, and although it is not a full translation of your sentence it makes the point clearly enough! wink

Con una correccion:

I think that you could also say: No fue algo que me gustara = It was not something that I liked! This sentence needs the imperfect subjunctive smile

Another option would be to say: No era algo que me gustaba using the imperfect indicative but as Shameless has commented the sentence with the imperfect is better!

Or even more simply: No me gustaba = I didn't like it

Please remember that this a translation into Spanish of a kind of expression that we would happily use in English. The Spanish way of thinking is considerably different from English and this is reflected in the fact that they would not necessarily phrase it in the same way.

I don't think that you need the subjunctive here, I have used the imperfect indicative tense, but I could be mistaken as I am not a native Spanish speaker so you may wish to wait for confirmation smile

I hope this helps smile

Corrijan mi español si es necesario, por favor smile

updated Sep 1, 2017
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
Feliz. Shouldn't you have 'me' in your literal translations? I could be wrong though ..... as any literal translation of this doesn't sound right to me. - billygoat, Aug 15, 2017
you are right, Billy an oversight on my part, thank you! :) - FELIZ77, Aug 15, 2017
Hi! This is very interesting. "No fue algo que me gustaba" needs either the subjunctive (no fue algo que me gustara) or the imperfect for "ser" (no era algo que me gustaba). However, I believe it sounds more natural to use the subjunctive here. - Shamelesspanish, Aug 15, 2017
Thank you very much for your advice, Shameless :) - FELIZ77, Aug 15, 2017