Home
Q&A
Una traducción de "Ser o Estar"

Una traducción de "Ser o Estar"

4
votes

¡Hola a todos! Estaba escuchando la canción "Ser o Estar" de Jesse y Joy, y traté de traducirla (creo que hice algunas partes mal). Lo siguiente es mi intento. ¿Es que ustedes lo pueden corregir?


No puedo esperar más sin tenerte junto a mí

Desesperación es que no estés aquí

Que no estés para verme caer

Ni me pueda tu voz levantar

Qué difícil se vuelve lograr respirar


I can't wait anymore without having you together with me

Despair that you're not here

That you're not here to see me fall

Nor can your voice lift me up

It becomes so difficult to breathe


No quiero ser

No quiero hablar

No quiero estar

Si tú no estás aquí


I don't want to be (exist)

I don't want to talk

I don't want to be (here)

If you're not here


No no puedo entender ya

Por qué no te dejas llevar

Dame una razón dos

Para soportar


I can't understand anymore

Why you don't let yourself carry (I had no idea here)

Give me a reason or two

To endure


Que no esté para verte caer

Y te pueda mi voz levantar

Qué difícil se vuelve lograr respirar


That I'm not here to see you fall

Or can my voice lift you up

It becomes so difficult to breathe


No quiero estar si tú no estás aquí

No entiendo lo que siento

Cómo pensar en dejarte ir

Si digo que no importa miento


I don't want to be here if you're not here

I don't understand what I feel

How to think about letting you go

If I tell you that it doesn't matter, I'm lying


Se empieza a notar si tú no estás

En mi comportamiento

No se te ocurra pensar en decirme adiós


It's beginning to be noticed if you're not here

In my behavior

It doesn't occur to you to say goodbye to me



También tenia otra pregunta - ¿por qué se utiliza tanto el subjuntivo? ¿Me pueden explicar por qué cantan

Desesperación es que no estés aquí

Que no estés para verme caer

Ni me pueda tu voz levantar

en lugar de esto?

Desesperación es que no estás aquí

Que no estás para verme caer

Ni me puede tu voz levantar


¡Muchas gracias!

671 views
updated Jul 6, 2017
edited by KRavishankar19
posted by KRavishankar19
very nice thread and very good translation, good job, amigo :) - 006595c6, Jul 6, 2017

6 Answers

5
votes

I think dejarse llevar means something like to get carried away or to lose control. Otherwise, your translation looks good to me. Translating songs used to be one of my favorite ways to practice Spanish. Glad to see I'm not the only one smile

I'll let someone else tackle the subjunctive here. I'd guess that he's just trying to be poetic but there's a good chance that I'm mistaken since subjunctive has always been confusing to me.

updated Jul 6, 2017
posted by alba3
wow, to get carried away, niiiiiiiiiiiice - 006595c6, Jul 6, 2017
always a pleasure to see you alba, your Spanish is fabulous - 006595c6, Jul 6, 2017
5
votes

The subjunctive requires certain "triggers" (See my article on the Subjunctive Link to subjunctive. One of the triggers is "siento que" or "me etristece que" followed by the subjoined clause with the verb in the subjunctive. This "trigger" indicates sadness.

In this case the word "desesperación" (meaning "despair" or "hopelessness") all by itself initiates the subjunctive of the three following verbs. The fifth line is not subjoined to "desesperación" as It begins a new sentence. There should have been a period after "levantar" on the fourth line.

I hope I have been clear enough on this. smile

updated Jul 6, 2017
edited by Daniela2041
posted by Daniela2041
4
votes

No no puedo entender ya

Por qué no te dejas llevar

Dame una razón dos

Para soportar

I just can't understand

Why you don't let yourself carry away

Give me a reason or two

To endure

Nice, the last two lines even rhyme!

updated Jul 6, 2017
posted by 006595c6
Just! I forget that ya can mean that. That makes a lot more sense. - alba3, Jul 6, 2017
4
votes

Desesperación es que no estés aquí

Que no estés para verme caer

Ni me pueda tu voz levantar

en lugar de esto?

Desesperación es que no estás aquí

Que no estás para verme caer

Ni me puede tu voz levantar

Well, in this case it is pretty clear. The speaker is not talking about actual facts but possibilities, so the subjunctive is used.

If they were actual facts, the second options would be correct.

Please have a look at Daniel's thread on the subjunctive.

updated Jul 6, 2017
edited by 006595c6
posted by 006595c6
4
votes

No puedo esperar más sin tenerte junto a mí

Desesperación es que no estés aquí

Que no estés para verme caer

Ni me pueda tu voz levantar

Qué difícil se vuelve lograr respirar

I can't wait anymore without having you by my side

(have you together with me sounds odd to me)

Despair means not having you here /by my side

That you're not here to see me fall

Nor can your voice lift me up

It becomes so difficult to breathe

Wait for native speakers to confirm wink

updated Jul 6, 2017
posted by 006595c6
You're right. Having you by my side or having you here with me sounds more natural. - alba3, Jul 6, 2017
3
votes

Se empieza a notar si tú no estás

En mi comportamiento

No se te ocurra pensar en decirme adiós

It's beginning to show if you're not here

In my behavior

Don't you dare say goodbye to me

Nice shot, however, please wait for native speakers.

updated Jul 6, 2017
posted by 006595c6
It's beginning to show! Excellent! - alba3, Jul 6, 2017
I thought that no se te ocurra pensar might mean something like that. Is that always the case with this phrase? - alba3, Jul 6, 2017
Heidi, I always thought you were a native speaker, amiga! ¿no es verdad? - FELIZ77, Jul 6, 2017
huh? feliz? - 006595c6, Jul 6, 2017
oh, sorry, feliz, native English speakers I meant!! - 006595c6, Jul 6, 2017