Home
Q&A
Indefinido o Imperfecto - necesito ayuda

Indefinido o Imperfecto - necesito ayuda

2
votes

I am concerned whether to use pretérito indefinido or pretérito imperfecto in a certain context which I will post here, down below: Take notice that I am a beginner, so please don't judge me for inevitable mistakes, thank you! smile

"Cuando tenía sólo un año fui a Gran Canaria con mis padres y mis abuelos. Cuando llegamos a el aeropuerto yo y mi abuelo comenzamos/comenzábamos argumentar si me tenía/tuve que poner/ponía/puse un sombrero o no."

Should "comenzar" "tener" be in indefinido or imperfecto? And do I need to conjugate "poner" or should I leave it in present tense?

I would be so grateful if you people who know these grammatical rules properly could help me out. Thanks in advance!

663 views
updated Feb 22, 2017
edited by MovableAdam
posted by MovableAdam
Welcome to SpanishDict. - rac1, Feb 20, 2017

1 Answer

2
votes

"Cuando tenía sólo un año fui a Gran Canaria con mis padres y mis abuelos. Cuando llegamos al aeropuerto yo y mi abuelo comenzamos a argumentar si me tenía que poner un sombrero o no."

A plus el= al

Comenzar a hacer algo

You began, sounds ended, so I pick preterit

Tenía- no end really, whether I was having to, I picked imperfect. (I might actually have said si iba a tener que ponerme, but I think tenía works.)

Tener que always has an infinitive.

I probably would have used discutir over argumentar. It sounds more appropriate to me, but that may be just me.

I am learner and preterit vs. imperfect is still a bit difficult for me so await other comments.

Do you want corrections to your English (inevitable rather than eventual, and people who know).

updated Feb 22, 2017
edited by bosquederoble
posted by bosquederoble