Home
Q&A
Objeto indirecto y directo

Objeto indirecto y directo

3
votes

Hola a todos,

Estoy leyendo La Ciudad de Las Bestias por Isabel Allende y tengo una duda sobre la frase.. <<.como si viera a mi mamá con toda claridad en una pantalla, sin poder tocarla o hablarle>>

¿Por qué ella ha usado tocar + la y hablar + le?

Muchísimas gracias,

Jane

899 views
updated Feb 4, 2017
posted by Jane_A

2 Answers

5
votes

¿Por qué ella ha usado tocar + la y hablar + le?

La is a direct object

Le is an indirect object

With tocar, who or what you touch is the direct object- you touch something.

With hablar who you speak to is the indirect object (what you are saying is the direct, implicitly usually but not always- I speak the truth to you).

We do the same in English (there is not always a one to one direct vs. indirect between Spanish and English but in this case it works)

We touch someone but talk to them.

Como si viera a mi mamá con toda claridad en una pantalla, sin poder tocarla o hablarle

As if I were seeing my mother with total clarity on a screen without being able to touch her or speak to her.

updated Feb 4, 2017
edited by bosquederoble
posted by bosquederoble
0 votar Jane_A Bosquederoble, thank you so much for the explanation. I understand perfectly now for other verbs such as preguntar and decir. grin - Jane_A, Feb 3, 2017
De nada. :) - bosquederoble, Feb 3, 2017
gracias bosque. muchas veces me he hecho un pequeño lio pensando en poner o no poner el "to" delante del her o el him. s - 000a35ff, Feb 3, 2017
Me ha ayudado mucho tu explicación. - 000a35ff, Feb 3, 2017
I wish it was always that easy: I give him it= I give it to him- one word order has "to" one does not. :) - bosquederoble, Feb 3, 2017
Have a badge, Bosque. - Daniela2041, Feb 4, 2017
2
votes

Bosquederoble, thank you so much for the explanation. I understand perfectly now for other verbs such as preguntar and decir.

grin

updated Feb 3, 2017
posted by Jane_A
De nada. :) - bosquederoble, Feb 3, 2017