Home
Q&A
"I didn't realise it was dangerous there"

"I didn't realise it was dangerous there"

3
votes

Is this:

no me di cuenta de que fuera peligroso ahí

or

no me di cuenta de que era peligroso ahí

?

Or something else?

Should you always use subjunctive with darse cuenta in the past?

778 views
updated Jan 14, 2017
posted by BailaBailaBaila

2 Answers

1
vote

I think Daniela´s explanation is reasonable although not just nuance but time factor is also important to determine the choice between subjunctive and indicative in this case.

I would say that "no me di cuenta de que fuera peligroso ahí" indicates that in the past I didn´t realize the danger that would happen (realization first - danger second. Basically the same as "No me di cuenta de que iba a ser peligroso").

"No me di cuenta de que era peligroso ahí" indicates that in the past the discovery of the danger and the realization happened at the same time.

The difference in nuance between the two is so minute that there are probably many people who really do not take the time to to choose - we just say what comes to mind and everything is ultimately understood and only a grammarian such as a former SD member Lazarus would even notice.

updated Jan 14, 2017
edited by 005faa61
posted by 005faa61
I wonder, could you use sería in place of fuera/iba a ser to give that same meaning? - bosquederoble, Jan 13, 2017
"Would" in English can mean "will" in past tense but not in Spanish, so "sería" should should be used just for future hypothetical - 005faa61, Jan 14, 2017
Okay, thanks. :) - bosquederoble, Jan 14, 2017
1
vote

I would go with your first answer, because it introduces a negative.

A positive statement with darse cuenta would not require the subjunctive.

With regard to the negative I have seen it stated both ways by native speakers, (which also I am) and I have even seen arguments over this problem. Many people would use the indicative.

My feeling is that is a matter of emphasis. If I am trying to express that "it might have been dangerous" Then I would use the subjunctive.

If I am emphasizing the fact that it was dangerous, then I would use the indicative.

This is one of those areas where the rules are not so rigid.

You will probably see a few different opinions pop up here. smile

updated Jan 13, 2017
posted by Daniela2041
Thank you. :) - bosquederoble, Jan 13, 2017
(I told you a few days ago there were ones I couldn't answer and had to leave for you and Julian). :) - bosquederoble, Jan 13, 2017