Home
Q&A
Different use of subjunctive

Different use of subjunctive

1
vote

I was having a conversation with a friend in Spanish (he's a native speaker), and I realized that he said "es como que yo te diga."

Why is the subjunctive used here? Why wouldn't it just be: es como que yo te digo..?

777 views
updated Oct 8, 2016
posted by olympiad42

3 Answers

2
votes

You can't use the indicative on account of the construction of the utterance.

Saying es como shows uncertainty (like giving an example of something that doesn't occur yet), that's why you need the subjunctive. Compare:

  1. Es como que yo te digo esto. (= fact)
  2. Es como que yo te diga esto. (= but I don't say it.)
updated Oct 8, 2016
edited by Oshnaj
posted by Oshnaj
You explained that better than I did. Thanks - margarita1943, Oct 8, 2016
1
vote

I am just an intermediate Spanish speaker, but it makes sense to me. If you translate it to English : It is how I may say it to you - then it sounds to me that it should be in the subjunctive. Could be wrong though!

updated Oct 8, 2016
posted by margarita1943
Hi Margarita, good to see you back again. How have you been traveling ? - ray76, Oct 8, 2016
Hi Ray. I've been in the Uk for a few months, now back in the Canary Islands - but have been really busy - in fact - he estado a tope! - margarita1943, Oct 8, 2016
0
votes

I suppose "es como que yo te diga" could be used, but this is a hypothetical situation, so the best subjunctive verbiage would be: es como si yo te dijera ......

updated Oct 8, 2016
posted by 005faa61