Home
Q&A
Quick proofread please thanks!

Quick proofread please thanks!

1
vote

Can you guys help me edit the Spanish translation of this sentence please? An explanation for the things you would change, add, or take out would be very appreciated! Thank you so much!

I need my sister to help me plan for Father's Day. A lot of people, including me and you, like to go out to eat on this day, but my sister does not.

Necesito a mi hermana para ayudarme planear el día de padre. A mucha gente, inclúyendomete, nos gusta comer afuera en este día, pero mi hermana no.

930 views
updated Jun 17, 2016
edited by Ramonaspiker
posted by Ramonaspiker
I will give my opinion at some point if no native speaker answers (it needs some work), but I don't want to interfere with an answer from one, so I will wait a while, unless you ask me otherwise. :) - bosquederoble, Jun 17, 2016
I would love to hear your opinion Bosque! - Ramonaspiker, Jun 17, 2016

1 Answer

3
votes

Necesito a mi hermana para ayudarme planear el día de padre. A mucha gente, inclúyendomete, nos gusta comer afuera en este día, pero mi hermana no.

My attempt:

Necesito que mi hermana me ayude a planear para el día del padre. A mucha gente, incluyéndonos a mí y a ti, nos gusta comer afuera (en) este día, pero a mi hermana no.

This is based on what sounds better to me, recognizing that I am not a native speaker.

If you change subject it is usually better to have a que phrase ( a few verbs like permitir can be done otherwise, but I don't think necesitar works that way)- so I chose necesitar que plus subjunctive- I need that my sister help me. Ayudar is connected to another infinitive by a. I have no idea whether you need the para there- but really you are planning for the day- planear la celebración, pero planear para el día. That may just be my preference. I think it is Día del padre, or de los padres- with an article.

I have no idea of my way of doing the incluyendo part is correct, but it is my best guess- and I would not mind native opinion on that. I don't think you need "en" but it is not necessarily wrong. Mi hermana remains the indirect object of the dropped/implicit gusta comer afuera and so needs an a.

updated Jun 18, 2016
edited by bosquederoble
posted by bosquederoble
Muy bien, Bosque! En efecto: el Día del Padre, de preferencia con mayúsculas. - LuisCache, Jun 17, 2016
Gracias, Luis. :) - bosquederoble, Jun 17, 2016
De nada, Bosque. - LuisCache, Jun 17, 2016
Planear está usado aqui como verbo transitivo. Por eso, yo diría: "que me ayude a planear la fiesta (el festejo) del Día del Padre. O algo similar - LuisCache, Jun 17, 2016
Gracias, Luis. :) - bosquederoble, Jun 17, 2016
Quizás incluso "planear algo para el Día del Padre"? o "hacer planes para el Día...? - bosquederoble, Jun 17, 2016
Thanks so much Bosque!! You really helped me understand the changes you made! Thank you too Luis! :) - Ramonaspiker, Jun 17, 2016