Home
Q&A
Editing a dialogue about gustar

Editing a dialogue about gustar

3
votes

Hi, I'm going to attempt to translate this dialogue. If there are errors, I would appreciate it if you could comment/answer below what you would say or what is wrong about a particular sentence. Thanks!

English: Q: Does she like pizza? A: Yes, she does like it. Q: What is your dad like? Does he like to run? A: My dad is a good baseball player. He likes to run everyday.

Español: P: ¿Ella le gusta la pizza? R: Si, a ella se la gusta. P: ¿Cómo es tu padre? A él le gusta correr? R: Mi padre es un bien jugador del béisbol. Le gusta correr todos los días.

Some topics I would like a better understanding of after searching hours for it on spanishdictionary: 1) When to use bueno(a), bien, and buen 2) When to use "a"

Some grammar things I guessed on: 1) Se lo gusta. I think that's right because la is the pizza (object) and since Ella is le, le + la= se la. 2) jugador del béisbol. De + el = del, but would I even need "el" before béisbol?

1517 views
updated Jun 2, 2016
posted by Ramonaspiker
Thank you JulianChivi :). I like the direct answer, but I would totally appreciate it a lot more if I could get some explanation for an explanation for why you said "¿A él le gusta correr? even though we already know it's about tu padre and why you said - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
"Bien jugador del béisbol". I don't understand when to use bien, buen, or bueno. I also would like to know if jugador de béisbol is correct to say. Thanks though! - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
"P: ¿A ella le gusta pizza? R: Sí, le gusta. P: ¿Cómo es tu padre? ¿A él le gusta correr? R: Mi padre es buen jugador del béisbol. Le gusta correr todos los días." You can also say just "Le gusta correr". "A él" is only for emphasis. "Jugador de béisbol" - 005faa61, May 28, 2016
..... is OK or you can say simply "beisbolista" - 005faa61, May 28, 2016
Thank you so much Julianchivi! Would "Mi padre es un jugador beisbolista buen" work too? and "Mi padre es bueno jugador beisbolista" work? - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
No, it should be "buen jugador del beisbol" or "buen beisbolista". When "bueno" preceeds the noun it must be "buen" - this is only for masculine gender. When it follows the noun it must be "bueno(a)" - 005faa61, May 29, 2016
Thank you so much JulianChivi! I got it now. - Ramonaspiker, May 29, 2016

3 Answers

3
votes

Are you learning with a teacher? I don't think it is ever wrong to add the a mí etc but it may sound old fashioned or very formal.

I use a mí, a tí a nosotros a vosotros for emphasis meaning as for me or just I like etc. I would particularly use it if I was in a group responding to a general question. However, with le or les it can be important for clarification[eg a el/ella/usted/ellos/as/ustedes. Be guided by your teacher particularly if you are preparing for an exam. Here is a lesson from a teacher from Spain. She says it is optional. However, having been to various Spanish speaking countries I know there can be regional differences.

gustar lesson

In the comments you asked about bueno and bien. People often muddle these in English [good and well] Bueno is an adjective; bien is an adverb.

Buen is a use of apocope which just means certain sounds or letters being dropped in some circumstances. When words like alguno, ninguno, primero and tercero are used before a masculine noun the o is dropped. Obviously if the noun is feminine it changes to an a.

There are particular rules with ciento which becomes cien and santo becomes san [San Francisco is an example] but feminine Santa Monica

You will get used to it as most adjectives go after the noun and you will tend to learn and remember the whole phrase eg buen amigo and buena amiga. Check out gran, grand y grande.

updated May 29, 2016
edited by Mardle
posted by Mardle
:) - ian-hill, May 28, 2016
Thank you very much for this very helpful explanation Mardle!! I'm not learning with a teacher anymore. Just reviewing some grammar concepts. - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
I would have to say "amigo bueno" if I put buen after amigo right? - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
This answer helps:http://www.spanishdict.com/answers/281949/buen-amigo-or-amigo-bueno but yes - apocope is only when in front of noun - Mardle, May 28, 2016
thank you so much for the link and explanation! I understand it much beternow - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
better now* - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016
You might want to find an article on apocope because not all adjectives lose the o. About Spanish.com is usually good. - Mardle, May 29, 2016
Ok thank you so much Mardle! - Ramonaspiker, May 29, 2016
1
vote

I mentioned in the comment section 'apócope' I have now found a good article if you need to know more about the topic

apocope explained

updated Jun 2, 2016
posted by Mardle
Wow what a great link you found!! This was so helpful. Thanks so much! - Ramonaspiker, Jun 1, 2016
Glad you noticed it. - Mardle, Jun 2, 2016
1
vote

I know you'd like a direct answer (who wouldn't), but it looks like you need to review the verb gustar and other verbs like it in Spanish. Here is the place to do that on this web site. Bosquederoble and others may come up with more websites to review this.

Verbs like gustar

updated May 28, 2016
posted by Jubilado
Thanks for the link Jubliado, but to be honest it made me even more confused. I read the review and did the practice test, but in the practice test, I didn't see many examples of "a". So now I have no idea when to use it. - Ramonaspiker, May 28, 2016