Home
Q&A
Please help - Grammar question

Please help - Grammar question

1
vote

For this sentence, is the grammar correct?

Ana no dio Bob el libro.

890 views
updated May 15, 2016
posted by krystal_16

2 Answers

3
votes

For this sentence, is the grammar correct?

Ana no dio Bob el libro.

No, you are missing elements:

Ana is the subject

El libro is the direct object

Bob is the indirect object, and generally should receive a "redundant" indirect object pronoun in addition to the necessary preposition a.

Ana no le dio el libro a Bob.

Ana did not (to him) give the book to Bob.

updated May 14, 2016
posted by bosquederoble
thank you! - krystal_16, May 14, 2016
You're welcome. :) - bosquederoble, May 14, 2016
0
votes

Of course, if you want to alter the phrasing, "Ana no le dio a Bob el libro."

Español es una lengua maleable =)

updated May 15, 2016
posted by joshuamarc