Home
Q&A
Subjunctive question regarding "tiene sentido"

Subjunctive question regarding "tiene sentido"

2
votes

Is it ever necessary to use the subjunctive in the following cases:

Tiene sentido que ..

No tiene sentido que ...

I thought that it might need to be used because you are expressing an opinion as a fact of some sort but I am not sure.

Gracias!

1886 views
updated May 13, 2016
posted by olympiad42

2 Answers

4
votes

I found this in wordreference.com: no tener sentido que se haga algo - to make no sense that (something be done?). That is subjunctive usage, but I also think that it could be followed by an infinitive: No tiene sentido llegar temprano. It makes no sense to arrive early.

We (at least you and I) need a native speaker to clear this up. I'll wait and see.

updated May 13, 2016
posted by Jubilado
This helped, thank you! - olympiad42, May 13, 2016
3
votes

I can give no rule from any textbook for this, but it just sounds good to me to do it this way.

Positively and negatively: Tiene sentido que (followed by an expression with the verb in the subjunctive)

Here's an example of the negative.

enter image description here

Here's an example of the positive, in question form. I prefer Jubilado's use of the infinitive for positive expressions.

enter image description here

updated May 13, 2016
posted by Daniela2041
Thank you for the examples, they are very clear. - olympiad42, May 13, 2016