Home
Q&A
Es vs. Eres in "What is your favorite book?"

Es vs. Eres in "What is your favorite book?"

1
vote

Qué eres tu libro favorito? or Qué es tu libro favorito? or neither?

I'm not quite sure how to phrase "What is your favorite book?" Thank you!

2746 views
updated Jan 4, 2016
posted by ome8217
Welcome to the forum , we want to help you so fill out your profile If you have a problem PM a mod Bienvenido al foro. Queremos ayudarle, entonces hay que llenar su perfil. Si hay un problema, envíe un mensaje personal (PM) - ray76, Jan 2, 2016
Go to this link http://www.spanishdict.com/answers/7690/ser-estar#q7690 - ray76, Jan 2, 2016
Thanks for the profile. You've got my vote. - Daniela2041, Jan 3, 2016
Daniela I just voted and there was a zero, please check again. - Jubilado, Jan 4, 2016

3 Answers

3
votes

Now that you have given your best effort (but haven't as yet filled out your profile) ahem. I will give you the correct translation.

¿Cuál es tu libro favorito? (or preferido) What is your book favorite?

Adjectives usually follow in Spanish, but can sometimes precede. (But that's whole 'nother can of worms smile )

We use "cuál" before the forms of "ser" for the English "what" when we want information and NOT a definition.

When to use "qué" and when to use "cuál" is a matter that gives English speakers nightmares. I have an article I use in my college classes which I may post here.

Buena suerte.--But please fill in your profile!!!

enter image description here

updated Jan 3, 2016
edited by Daniela2041
posted by Daniela2041
You'll start getting votes when you put in your profile. - Daniela2041, Jan 3, 2016
BTW, I didn't post this as much for the questioner as I did for the members, as there seems to be a little confusion about this. - Daniela2041, Jan 3, 2016
Very helpful post, amiga ...I am sure that many members will benefit from your clear explanation :) - FELIZ77, Jan 3, 2016
Thanks for you post and clarification on "cuál"! - Jubilado, Jan 3, 2016
Thank you for your explanation! I was having a bit of a brain fart. - ome8217, Jan 3, 2016
6
votes

Pretty good post but you could have begun with "Please".

You can type your sentence in the translator and see what you get. It's located on the home page of the website.

I'm answering to clarify an obvious error in your understanding of the words tú and tu. The first is the personal pronoun for "you singular and familiar" that would be written with the verb form eres = tú eres - you are.

The second tu is the second person singular possessive pronoun "your familar" It would be used in an expression like tu libro = "your book".

You should also use the question word cuál in this sentence because the meaning is "which" meaning "what one of many possible choices" see Daniela's answer it's much better.

Please fill our your profile and I will give you a vote.

updated Jan 3, 2016
edited by Jubilado
posted by Jubilado
:) - ray76, Jan 2, 2016
Jubilado this is an Estar /Ser question again the link is needed or that post you had a few days ago - ray76, Jan 2, 2016
:) - ian-hill, Jan 2, 2016
Sorry, mi amor, this is not dealing with "ser" and "estar" but "tú" and "tu" play a part as Jubi has stated. - Daniela2041, Jan 3, 2016
Ray, I don't think it's Ser vs Estar. I really think it's the confusion with "tu" that I addressed. However if this person completes "their" profile I will post the link as an edit to my answer. No use talking to an empty chair! - Jubilado, Jan 3, 2016
Jubi, your use of "cuál" having to do with "which" meaning "what one of many possible choices", used to be taught in the schools, but we native speakers look at it from a whole different standpoint. And it's a lot easier to understand. - Daniela2041, Jan 3, 2016
4
votes

Definitely not "eres," as it is the conjugation of "ser" for the familiar second-person singular subject pronoun, "tú." "Tú" is not the subject of your sentence.

Now, would you please go back to your profile page and fill in your level of proficiency in both English and Spanish so people who would like to communicate with you will know the best way to do so? It also helps to know whether you're male or female and even a little something about you, such as your reason for joining Spanishdict or even where you're from and how you spend your time. That last part is optional, but we really, really need to know how fluent you are in English and Spanish.

updated Jan 2, 2016
posted by AnnRon
Agree. - Jubilado, Jan 2, 2016
:) - ian-hill, Jan 2, 2016