Home
Q&A
Why is the subjunctive used in the negative here?

Why is the subjunctive used in the negative here?

1
vote

Question #16

No he visto a nadie que ___ un abrigo hoy, no hace frío.

My answer: lleva


Correct answer: lleve

Why is the subjunctive used? Isn't this statement of a fact or am I reading it wrong? (I'm reading it as "I haven't seen anyone who's wearing a coat today, it's not cold.") Does the reason have something to do with the negation used/the fact that it's warm outside?

1353 views
updated Oct 20, 2015
edited by trig_king87
posted by trig_king87

2 Answers

2
votes

In the textbooks, this construction is called "The subjunctive of denial"

Examples:

No conozco a nadie que hable japonés. Pero sí que conozco a algunos que hablan francés.

No creo que José esté loco. Pero estoy segura de que su hermana está muy loca.

Notice in the negative statmemts---subjunctive. In the postive ones, --indicative.

I am in the process or writing up a series of lessons on the subjunctive so stay tuned.

enter image description here

updated Oct 20, 2015
posted by Daniela2041
2
votes

It is because is an adjetive sentence and is in negative mode and is preceded by "que". I will write an example.

No he visto a nadie feo.

No he visto a nadie QUE SEA es feo.

updated Oct 20, 2015
edited by 000a35ff
posted by 000a35ff