Home
Q&A
Purpose of voting

Purpose of voting

8
votes

Could someone explain the purpose of voting? It's the only forum where I've come across this practice.

2493 views
updated Sep 14, 2015
edited by mojac
posted by mojac
Now you have two votes! Isn't it exciting? - annierats, Sep 8, 2015
Wow! you already have four votes--two additional in just eleven minutes. Keep this up and you'll earn a badge. :>) - AnnRon, Sep 8, 2015
Now you have 5 - that means you have one badge more .:) - ian-hill, Sep 8, 2015
Many forums have voting systems. - roveg, Sep 8, 2015
Everyone gets a vote from me on this thread on this important topic. Thanks for the question. - Sassette, Sep 8, 2015

6 Answers

7
votes

Before voting was introduced many years ago now, we discussed it and at first I was against the idea.

I have since changed my mind - at least it shows that someone probably read your post - before voting.

updated Sep 14, 2015
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
Es cien porciento verdad... :) ian-hill ! I read and then vote only if I like........ - nepal15, Sep 14, 2015
7
votes

It doesn't hurt anything, and for some of us it serves as a tiny additional motivator. We vote our thanks for help and our appreciation of each other's contributions. It helps to impart a sense of community.

updated Sep 10, 2015
posted by AnnRon
I agree - rac1, Sep 8, 2015
I disagree. I put in a lot of effort in my posts and to see me get such few votes and get passed up...how is that not supposed to hurt me? - Sassette, Sep 9, 2015
...I'm not exactly a popular member in this community and voting really brings that out. But this site should be about learning and sharing, not popularity. - Sassette, Sep 9, 2015
6
votes

I look forward to 4000 reps: less advertising.

A bit less mercenary: I derive value from what people say here; I try to return value with entertaining posts. Votes are a rough but useful indication of what things succeed.

updated Sep 10, 2015
posted by roveg
:) - ian-hill, Sep 8, 2015
yes, I vote for you when I understand your sentence, which is not always.. Probably I don't read it right. - annierats, Sep 10, 2015
6
votes

When you reach certain points targets, the mods send you prizes. For the first 5,000 rep they send you vouchers for your local shopping mall. At 10,000 it's a steak dinner. 20,000 gets you a mini-break to a Spanish-speaking country of your choosing. 50,000 is a week in an all-expenses-paid-for luxury resort. Personally, I can't wait for 100,000, because that's a car !!

All of which is complete lies, by the way.

In truth, I guess it's just a simple way of encouraging folk to continue to participate in the forum as they watch their points grow, a bit like some folk treat Facebook as they watch their number of 'friends' grow and accumulate more and more 'likes' for posts that they've shared...

In Britain there's a TV games show presenter called Bruce Forsyth, aka 'Brucie', who I believe is now about 170 years old (he was already very elderly when I first saw him on telly as a kid). He uses a catchphrase (I'm not sure if he actually coined it himself or plagiarised it from another game show):

Brucie to audience: What do points make ?

Audience to Brucie: Prizes !!!

enter image description here

updated Sep 9, 2015
edited by Faldaesque
posted by Faldaesque
I'm hoping for trip to Cuba.. - annierats, Sep 8, 2015
Me too - about 50,000,000 that one I think. - ian-hill, Sep 8, 2015
6
votes

The one thing I can think of is that with voting you get to see the best answers first. In my opinion this is a great idea for the Q&A section because some people have better answers than others to issues like grammar questions. And for those seeking answers it's faster to see the best answers at the top of the list.

Voting for games, however, is a different situation in my view because much of the time there really isn't a clear "best answer" and voting is so subjective. One of the biggest factors is you tend to get more votes if you answer earlier rather than later. Some issues attract more votes than others. This all has nothing to do with the quality of the entry. So voting on games has sullied my SD experience and I wish this site would get rid of voting on games. Maybe the administrators feel that we all get addicted to voting so we'll keep participating. I don't know.

At least you don't get any money or love for votes. So I'm not missing out on all that much...well, that's what I tell myself when I get upset with the voting smile .

updated Sep 9, 2015
edited by Sassette
posted by Sassette
Best answer is at the behest of the original poster of the thread. I make it for a number of different reasons - not always most votes, sometimes originality or effort, especially if any corrections have been made. - ian-hill, Sep 8, 2015
I could care less about who gets the best answer. I look at the amount of votes only. - Sassette, Sep 9, 2015
4
votes

The votes get you badges.

You can sell your badges on e-bay!

Or, if you're lucky, you may win a prize.. ( o possibly not, I'm losing heart).

updated Sep 8, 2015
posted by annierats
lol - Sassette, Sep 8, 2015
Don't ever lose heart...you add spice to the place. ♥ - rac1, Sep 8, 2015