Home
Q&A
Indirect speech...

Indirect speech...

0
votes

I've got an exercise to do where I have to complete a sentence in indirect speech. The original is the following (someone has asked for directions): "Sigan todo recto y giren a la izquierda y ya la encontrarán".

The sentence I should complete is: "Ha dicho que...."

I have come to understand that you normally transform the imperative into a conditional like "girara" (conditional II), but my solutions tell me to use the subjunctivo. Why?

2372 views
updated Feb 10, 2015
posted by el_gato_de_schroedinger
Please fill out your profile so that we may better help you . Bienvenido al foro , buena suerte amiga. - ray76, Feb 10, 2015

1 Answer

3
votes

Hi there,

It looks like there's some mixup of terminology.

Conditional II in Spanish ("condicional compuesto" unless I'm wrong) - "habría girado"

"Girara" - imperfect subjunctive

The imperative is transformed into imperfect subjunctive, so your 'girara' is actually on the right track, only it needs to agree with the subject.

Now, you do need a conditional for that "encontrarán" because the future tense is transformed into a conditional but you only need the "condicional simple" with the '-ía' ending (again, needs to agree with the subject).

Want to give it a try?

updated Feb 10, 2015
edited by Manity
posted by Manity