Home
Q&A
Confusion over Past Participles as Adjectives

Confusion over Past Participles as Adjectives

5
votes

I know how to form past participles from the infinitives of verbs. I also know that Spanish has a strong preference for agreement between noun & adjective in terms of person & number. I am aware there are certain exceptions to the agreement rules.

However, I remain confused about when a past participle should agree. It seems to me that some do while others don’t, & I can’t discern any pattern.

For example, I’m pretty sure you would talk of a ‘película conocida’ (& not ‘conocido’), yet I’m also pretty sure you would talk of a ‘película hecho en colores’ (& not ‘hecha’), but I don’t understand why one should agree yet the other not.

Any guidance would be appreciated, gracias.

1067 views
updated Jan 26, 2015
posted by Faldaesque
Yo diría "ayer vi una película hecha en blanco y negro", nunca "hecho"... Y película conocida, aburrida, entretenida, divertida, etc, en femenino... - Cordobesa, Jan 26, 2015
Good detail to review. Thanks! - Jubilado, Jan 26, 2015

1 Answer

6
votes

Cordobesa already replied to your specific example. I'm not totally sure if the confusion I experience over past participles is the same as what you mean here, so let me know if this is different:

Te hemos conocido desde 1980. - part of the verb, no agreement

Soy conocida en España. - adjective, agreement

Estamos satisfechos con la compra. - adjective, agreement

Habíamos satisfecho las rígidas exigencias. - part of the verb, no agreement

With your example about the movie, "he hecho esta película con el corazón" vs. "esta película está hecha con el corazón".

updated Jan 26, 2015
posted by Manity
No, I thnink I've just seen 'hecho' used wrongly in the past & assumed it doesn't agree. Now I know it does. Thanks, everyone :-) - Faldaesque, Jan 26, 2015
Good stuff, it's nice to have it cleared up :) - Manity, Jan 26, 2015