Home
Q&A
How do I know the right translation

How do I know the right translation

2
votes

When using the translator on this site a lot of different ways on how to say the phrase or sentence pops up when I type it in to see how to say something or if I said something right but sometimes there will be two of the some results and one different how do I know which one is correct?

1325 views
updated Oct 10, 2014
posted by Sc89
Good advice and answers from HCAStudent and annierats. Tip: If you are interested in learning how to translate, work on Spanish to English since you have a good intuition for correct English. - Jubilado, Oct 9, 2014

5 Answers

5
votes

Use any translator as a dictionary and you do the translation.

Else, it is like you wanting to develop muscles but let other people lift the weights, but you walk up to them and that action, in your mind, is more than satisfactory to you.

Guess who is going to develop those muscles.

updated Oct 10, 2014
edited by chileno
posted by chileno
4
votes

Like any translator, this one is imperfect. The only surefire way to know which is correct is to carefully review each word. Remember, the translator only gives you a suggestion. You are responsible for making sure it is correct!

Hope this helps!

updated Nov 23, 2014
posted by 00ffada9
4
votes

Only through experience and exposure to the language will you even begin to tell if the translator is close. That is the real value of this forum. The participants share their experience and knowledge of the language. And we are fortunate to have a few native speakers who help us out. There is both experience and exposure to be gained here but only if you stay and apply yourself.

Best of luck and I hope to see you around.

updated Oct 10, 2014
edited by gringojrf
posted by gringojrf
I agree , Gringo :) - FELIZ77, Oct 10, 2014
4
votes

Hello Sc,

Welcome to the SpanishDict forum smile

When using the translator on this site a lot of different ways on how to say the phrase or sentence pops up when I type it in to see how to say something or if I said something right but sometimes there will be two of the some results and one different how do I know which one is correct?

As Annie rigtly said, you can't tell! I encourage people to have a go or attempt to answer their question or post their best attempt but because I don't have much confidence in online translator machines, at least not the ones most people use, I don't suggest/recommend that people use the machine translators here

I have come across more accurate apps on both my Blackberry and Samsung Galaxy S3 smartphone which were available on Blackberry market (Rim) and Android

Navita translator was one of the better ones it used Google, Bing and another search engine translator but I don't think it was Microsoft!.

Using language translators can never be a genuine subsutitute for making the effort to learn a language properly and there are so many resources here on SpanishDict which are completely free: Paralee's 60 mini-videos in Spanish (admittedly only about 30 for learning English) the grammar section, and the forum where you can ask questions. In addition , you can arrange a Skype session with a Spanish native for free and help each other learn your reciprocal languages! wink

Finally, a friendly warning: the more you allow yourself anyone allows them self, to become dependent on machine translators the slower your rate progress will be in learning Spanish/English! They cannot ever take the place of learning to communicate effectively and confidently in any language;..they can simply be one tool which should be used sparingly in the full recognition that they not infallible! wink

I hope this helps smile

updated Oct 10, 2014
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
I agree with you. - annierats, Oct 10, 2014
Thank you, Annie :) - FELIZ77, Oct 10, 2014
3
votes

You don't. Machine translations are very clever but they translate word by word and are not always what a person would say. They are getting better all the time, but I hope they will never make us humans redundant. As your Spanish gets better you will be able to see which translation is likely to suit your particular sentence.

updated Oct 9, 2014
posted by annierats
Oh I don't know. I think it would be useful to have a little gadget that translates everything I said into a foreign language. Might be useful. - 00ffada9, Oct 9, 2014
Might be useful but very innacurate too Hca ;Problem is, the more inexperienced a person is the more they rely too heavily on translators but the irony is they cannot tell which is the correct answer! When a person can tell which the right answer is .... - FELIZ77, Oct 9, 2014
(and there might not even be a correct answer given ) they could probably have done amuch better job without it lol - FELIZ77, Oct 9, 2014
Ha ha, good point Feliz! - 00ffada9, Oct 9, 2014