Home
Q&A
Tiene el tamaño de un huevo?

Tiene el tamaño de un huevo?

2
votes

I thought tiene meant he/she but according to the web site I was on this sentence means "it is the size of an egg." Can anyone explain why Tiene suddenly becomes "it" in place of eso or esto? Thanks

Later... Thanks for all the answers I believe the web site that was teaching me was wrong. I also translated this sentence into Do you have the size of a egg. They give me a wrong answer because according to them it mean "It is a size of an egg". Or "it's the size of an egg." Again being that I never heard tiene used for "it is a" I was was very confused. Thanks for your time.

2505 views
updated Aug 19, 2014
edited by Growabeard
posted by Growabeard
Please fill out your profile so that we may better help you .Bienvenido al fora , buena suerte amiga. - ray76, Aug 18, 2014

7 Answers

5
votes

¿Tiene el tamaño de un huevo? = Do you have the size of an egg?

updated Aug 18, 2014
posted by ian-hill
:) - FELIZ77, Aug 17, 2014
5
votes

I'm confused about your question

It is the size of an egg - (ello) es del tamaño de un huevo.

(ello/él/ella) tiene el tamaño de un huevo - (it/he/she) has the size of an egg

but in Spanish depending on the context either we use "eso(that)" instead "it(ello)" or we just don't use anything. e.g

"it's the size of an egg" -"es del tamaño de un huevo"

"it has the size of an egg" - "Eso tiene el tamaño de un huevo" or "Tiene el tamaño de un huevo"

but I believe that I did not understand the question so better wait for another reply enter image description here

updated Aug 18, 2014
posted by 003e54f5
:) - ian-hill, Aug 17, 2014
Me too. :) - ian-hill, Aug 17, 2014
5
votes

You are confused about the meaning of 'tiene'.

Check out this conjugation page for the verb tener and you will understand it better. grin

enter image description here

updated Aug 18, 2014
edited by 007c5fc1
posted by 007c5fc1
4
votes

Is it the size of an egg = Es del tamaño de un huevo?

Tiene el tamaño de un huevo? = Does it have the size of an egg?

Does it help?

updated Aug 19, 2014
posted by chileno
:) - FELIZ77, Aug 19, 2014
Am I correct in asking "Does it have the size of an egg?"? - chileno, Aug 19, 2014
Chileno, we would say: is it the size of an agg/is it the same size as an egg? - FELIZ77, Aug 19, 2014
I understand. What I am asking if it is grammatically correct. Usage is something else. - chileno, Aug 19, 2014
4
votes

Hello Growabeard

Welcome to the SpanishDict forum. )

You asked,

I thought tiene meant he/she but according to the web site I was on this sentence means "it is the size of an egg." Can anyone explain why Tiene suddenly becomes "it" in place of eso or esto? Thanks

Firstly, the word tiene comes from the verb tener = to have (The principal verb meaning to have , possess, own)

It is important to understand/remember that:

The conjugation tiene can be translated: he has / she has, you have (Ud polite form ) and is the 3rd person singular form which is also used to signify the impersonal form it has

Whereas, in English, we say it is the size of an egg, the Spanish often (but not always) say: Tiene el tamaño de un huevo. = It is (literally has) the size of an egg = (ello).

.This is because we would not really say (In UK anyway) it has the size of an egg!

You could also say: Es del temaño de un huevo. = It is the size of an egg

However, it does depend on the context as Pablo rightly says...it all depends on what you want or are trying to say! wink

I believe that the word tiene can carry the meaning it has without the need for the word ello =it) which I have purposely placed in brackets!

I hope this helps (is what you were asking/wanting to know!) smile

updated Aug 19, 2014
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
3
votes

There are many verbs that can be translated as "to be" in English. The most obvious are ser and estar. But tener also can be translated as "to be". There are others as well although I cannot think of any right now.

Type Tener into the translator and "to be" is one of the basic translations.

As to the "it" part. Spanish generally does not have a nueter like English. If a thing can be identified then it has a gender. But those things that cannot be identified are nueter is Spanish as well. So the third person singular is normally thought of as he/she/you(formal; it also include "it".

updated Aug 19, 2014
edited by gringojrf
posted by gringojrf
:) - FELIZ77, Aug 19, 2014
2
votes

In Spanish tener (to have) is used in many cases where in English we would use the verb "to be" ... for example .. In english we will say ,, I am hungry ,, but in spanish we will say "tengo hambre" ( I have hunger), like wise ,, in english ,, I am 35 years old ,, but in spanish ,, tengo 35 años (I have 35 years), similarly,, are you thirsty? Tienes sed (do you have thirst?) .. and similarly ,, you are right ,, tienes razón (you have reason) .. So now you can appreciate that in a lot of contexts whereas the english employs the verb "to be" (am, are, is etc.) The spanish would rather use the verb "tener" (to have) .... so likewise ... tiene el tamaño de un huevo .. means .. it has the size of an egg .. ir it is the size of an egg ..

And as far as eso and esto are concened .. tney are demonstrative pronouns and you can use them along with the sentence you have mentioned above..

You can say ... ésto tiene el tamaño de un huevo (this one is the size of an egg) or eso tiene el tamaño de un huevo .. that one is the size of an egg ..

Hope this helps

updated Aug 18, 2014
posted by 00b055e0