Home
Q&A
Help with preterite and imperfect translation.

Help with preterite and imperfect translation.

3
votes

If i wanted to say. "I hurt myself." Would id o so in preterite or imperfect. why?

3092 views
updated Jun 24, 2014
posted by jackspratt999

5 Answers

5
votes

"¡Me lastimé!" would mean "I hurt myself!" You would use this when something suddenly happens or happens a definite amount of times in the past. We would use the preterite in this situation.

The imperfect indicative would be used when the action was habitually done in the past. For example...

As a child, I would hurt myself falling off of my bike.

De niño, me lastimaba cayendo de mi bicicleta.

Of course, there are other uses for the preterite and imperfect tenses, so feel free to check this link for their uses and other verb forms.

updated Jun 24, 2014
posted by GuitarWarrior
Good answer :) - FELIZ77, Jun 23, 2014
Nice answer :) - Kiwi-Girl, Jun 23, 2014
¡Gracias amigos! - GuitarWarrior, Jun 23, 2014
4
votes

Perhaps you'd find this free ebook to be useful.

Preterite vs imperfect

updated Jun 24, 2014
posted by Kiwi-Girl
Anyone would find that useful. You are a good resource on this site. Never leave! - Jubilado, Jun 23, 2014
Great link :) - FELIZ77, Jun 23, 2014
@Julilado - lol, thanks guys :) - Kiwi-Girl, Jun 23, 2014
Great link - thanks so much! - Motema15, Jun 24, 2014
3
votes

Hello Jack,

Welcome to the SpanishDict forum. smile

You asked,

If i wanted to say. "I hurt myself." Would id o so in preterite or imperfect. why?

Well, basically speaking, you use the imperfect indicative tense in Spanish when you want to say" I was reading (doing something)" / or " I used to play tennis (do something)" (ie: an habitual action) whereas the you would use the preterite indicative (simple past) for actions that have been completed at some time in the past!

Assuming that you were not in the habit of hurting yourself (accident prone/or self harming) I would say that you would use the preterite tense because you are talking about an action that has already been completed! wink

There are often a number of valid /acceptable ways to express the same idea in any language and Spanish is no exception to this general practice!

One way to say I hurt myself uses the verb construction: hacerse daño

Me hice daño = I hurt myself

I hope this helps. smile

updated Jun 24, 2014
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
Great idea, amigo. Just one thing: the verb would be "Me *hice* daño." to agree with the subject "yo." - GuitarWarrior, Jun 23, 2014
THank you very much, Guitar yes, I almost forgot to change the conjugation to match my changed sentence :) - FELIZ77, Jun 23, 2014
3
votes

Would I do so in preterite or imperfect.

You would do so in preterite because you are not talking about a past action that occurred over an expressed or implied passage of time.

Now, if you wanted to say "I was hurting myself while the phone was ringing." you would use the imperfect, but who would say that!

updated Jun 24, 2014
edited by Jubilado
posted by Jubilado
Good answer :) - FELIZ77, Jun 23, 2014
1
vote

GuitarWarrior ''I would hurt'' would be conditional tense. Imperfect would be like I was hurting or I used to be in pain.

updated Jun 23, 2014
posted by Reid13
Hi Reid. Your post is true. But "would" also has uses other than the conditional tense, and in this example it is being used to express a habitual past action. See the 4th definition of this site: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/would?s=t - GuitarWarrior, Jun 23, 2014
I agree with GW :) - Kiwi-Girl, Jun 23, 2014