Home
Q&A
Help with "¿Por qué quiero aprender inglés?"

Help with "¿Por qué quiero aprender inglés?"

3
votes

Hi everyone smile I'm new here and just need help with a simple question.

Whilst talking to a Spanish language exchange partner, I asked him, "¿Por qué te aprendes inglés?" meaning 'why do you learn English?' (or in more words, 'why do you want to learn English?') He corrected me with "¿Por qué quiero aprender inglés? " However, I was under the impression that 'quiero' would be referring to myself, thus 'Why do I want to learn English?' so it didn't really make sense to me.

Can anyone shed some light on this for me? It'd be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

1012 views
updated May 24, 2014
posted by inkstained
Welcome to the forum! It will help us to help you if you complete your profile information, especially as it relates to language ability. - rac1, May 23, 2014
Great question! - jphip, May 24, 2014

3 Answers

4
votes

He was talking about himself to correct you- well, a correction/ the way he understands and speaks. Por qué te aprendes íngles sounds odd but is understood.

You should have said ¿Por qué quiere(s) aprender español?

updated May 24, 2014
edited by jphip
posted by jphip
Thank you! :) - inkstained, May 24, 2014
Great response, Jp :) - FELIZ77, May 24, 2014
3
votes

I agree with Jp. I believe that he was trying to correct you by ascertaining what you were trying to say. It was his way of saying Is this what you really want to know?

He corrected me with "¿Por qué quiero aprender inglés?

As if to say, is this the question you want me to answer: Why do I want to learn English?

He could alternatively have said: we say it like this: ¿Por qué quieres aprender inglés? = Why do you want to learn English?

Obviously you would phrase the question correctly like this if you were asking him: ¿Por qué quieres aprender inglés? = Why do you want to learn English? He wasn't so much answering your question as...

1 Trying to understand the question you were asking him and asking you for clarification of this

2 showing you how to say it properly in his native language: Spanish

I hope this helps to clarify things for you smile

updated May 24, 2014
edited by FELIZ77
posted by FELIZ77
Yep, I understand now. Thank you for your swift answers :) - inkstained, May 24, 2014
Good I'm glad you understand what he meant, now :) - FELIZ77, May 24, 2014
You are welcome :) - FELIZ77, May 24, 2014
Great addition and explanation! - jphip, May 24, 2014
Thanks Jp :) - FELIZ77, May 24, 2014
2
votes

Try the translator above - it will help you.

updated May 24, 2014
posted by ian-hill
Sorry but I don't think you read my question correctly. I already know what it means - I'd like to know why he said that. - inkstained, May 24, 2014
Oh sorry. - ian-hill, May 24, 2014