Do i use estoy or soy in this sentence?
yo soy miembro el club de _____. or estoy miembro el club de ______.
8 Answers
Your homework question has been answered correctly many times here, but in this case it is not a question of permanent, temporary, or hesitant - ser must be used. Even if you are only temporary, you must still discribe your current nature of being and not your state of being, ie: Soy miembro provisional/temporal del club.
The only way to use estar would be to provide context that you are at this club at the moment of speaking, but you would still need to indicate permanent or temporary as your status, ie: Estoy (aquí) de miembro/miembro temporal del club.
To indicate being hesitant you would still use ser, ie: Quizás sea miembro del club.
You would normally use ' ser', but if you were just a temporary member, or hesitant about your membership, you could use 'estar'.
yo soy is correct as you are permanently part of the club
soy--used in permanent things like occupation and nationality
estoy-- used in temporary things like place and time
Es soy and you need a "de" after miembro
- Soy miembro del club de...
Ser I beleive, Yo soy. Because it is describing something you are doing, and not a state you are in.
that i believe would be soy.
Soy
Soy would be more appropriate because ''soy" means like "I am" and "estoy" means like "I am being".
