Home
Q&A
Use of 'shall' and 'will' in conditional sentences.

Use of 'shall' and 'will' in conditional sentences.

2
votes

My understanding is that the ''ll' (double L contraction for will and shall) mustn't be used after If (conditional sentences). Well, I've just bumped into this sentence:

  • If you'll clear the table, I'll wash the dishes.

If my assumption is wrong and that's correct, can it be used in all contexts?

Thanks in advance.

3046 views
updated Sep 7, 2013
edited by 00483d91
posted by 00483d91

2 Answers

3
votes

Yes it can be used as shown by you.

In fact it is always used like that unless emphasis is needed:

If you will clear the table" - this of course requires another clause to be a conditional sentence.

Will can also be used like this:

If you will always argue with me I will not talk to you.

=

If you insist on arguing with me I will not talk to you.

All contractions can be uncontracted for emphasis.

"Yes, he's here" - " Yes he is here" etc.

Normally contractions are not used in formal writing.

updated Sep 7, 2013
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
Good explanation. Contracted "ll"-s in conditional sentences make the request sound a bit nicer and softer, I rarely see them in their full form. - Manity, Sep 6, 2013
Gandalf, as in: "You shall not pass". He wasn't being soft down there. :D - 00483d91, Sep 6, 2013
Muhaha, yeah! How was that phrase translated in Spanish? No vas a pasar, fancy future tense, something altogether different? - Manity, Sep 6, 2013
"No puedes pasar" in Spanish (Spain) and "No lograrás pasar" in Latin Spanish. - 00483d91, Sep 6, 2013
Using lograr sounds quite fancy to me, I like how neither version used a literal translation. I'm really impressed you were able to produce both version practically off the top of your head. - Manity, Sep 6, 2013
I actually went to YouTube and checked the clips in 'neutral' and 'Latin' Spanish. In movies, when dubbed, it's not all about perfect translation (they're terrible sometimes) but lip-sync. - 00483d91, Sep 6, 2013
Ah, yes, of course. The sad reality of dubbing movies. - Manity, Sep 6, 2013
0
votes

Then, may I assume that the following is incorrect?:

  • Tom: Frank, wash the dishes.
  • Frank: If you'll clear the table.

Should be?: If you clear the table.

updated Sep 6, 2013
posted by 00483d91
Yes that sounds more natural but both answers are ok. - ian-hill, Sep 6, 2013
Thank you very much! :) - 00483d91, Sep 6, 2013
Strangely - Yes, if you are "willing" to clear the table. Voluntad. This will is nothing to do with the future really. - ian-hill, Sep 6, 2013