Home
Q&A
In this scenario Estar or Ser

In this scenario Estar or Ser

2
votes

Cuando yo quiero dice "I am a Korean American", es necessario que uso estar or ser?

Yo estoy coreano americano

o

Yo soy coreano americano

Gracias!

1022 views
updated Sep 10, 2013
posted by nflrocks123

3 Answers

3
votes

En este caso se usa el verbo "ser".

Your nationality/ethnicity is part of who you are, so it fits under the category of "permanent" characteristics with which we use the verb "ser."

updated Sep 8, 2013
posted by PumpkinCalabaza
Gracias! - nflrocks123, Sep 5, 2013
2
votes

I don't know if you were ever taught this, but when I was in Spanish I we were taught the rhyme "To talk about how you feel and where you are, always use the verb estar", so therefore your nationality fits under "who you are", for ser.

This always helped me, so I hope maybe it can help you. Good luck!

updated Sep 11, 2013
edited by indiecookie
posted by indiecookie
Not quite Indie... - Mainer, Sep 8, 2013
It's actually "how you feel and where you are." - penguinoaks, Sep 9, 2013
WOW. Maybe I need to get some sleep or something. It's fixed- thank you. - indiecookie, Sep 10, 2013
1
vote

Often time certain errors make something snap and I remember the lesson permanently. Indiecookie, this should be one of those moments. To talk about how you feel/how you are always use estar, to talk about who you are always use ser, just as PumpkinC pointed out.

updated Sep 10, 2013
posted by Mainer
Yes, this is one of those moments indeed. Thanks. - indiecookie, Sep 10, 2013