Home
Q&A
Question about the subjunctive?

Question about the subjunctive?

1
vote

Hi! I don't have a teacher so i really can't ask one.--Anyways, I looked at this question and I thought the answer should be in present perfect subjunctive but a native speaker says it's in present perfect...

No hay nadie que _____ (haber) visto la película.

I thought it was haya--because "nadie"..

762 views
updated Aug 15, 2013
posted by englishespanol
This is the same question you ask yesterday..... - rac1, Aug 15, 2013

2 Answers

1
vote

Correct. smile

Now, my question to you is, do you know English grammar? I mean really know?

Or should I say "remember"?

In any case that's my question.

updated Aug 15, 2013
posted by chileno
Haha true :) - englishespanol, Aug 15, 2013
1
vote

I believe it should be the subjunctive.

There is a main/subordinate clause, and it is a vague or indefinite antecedent sentence.

"No hay nadie que haya visto la película."

"There isn't anyone who has seen the movie."

updated Aug 15, 2013
posted by amaken