Home
Q&A
Am I confused or is this a mistake?

Am I confused or is this a mistake?

1
vote

In one of the practice games over on Visual Link, the translation given for “We have never liked to count them (los frijoles)” is “Nunca nos ha gustado contarlos.” I I thought it should be “Nunca nos hemos gustado contarlos.” What is it that I don’t understand?

890 views
updated Aug 13, 2013
posted by AnnRon

2 Answers

2
votes

“Nunca nos ha gustado contarlos.

This is correct because "ha gustado" refers to the action of counting and not to "us." In English: Counting them has never pleased us.

Translating gustar to like rather than to please will always cause confusion because doing so creates a subject that isn´t.

updated Aug 13, 2013
posted by 005faa61
I hadn't thought about it like that, but it makes perfect sense. Thanks. - AnnRon, Aug 13, 2013
1
vote

Not sure, but isn't "ha gustado" referring to "counting", not "we" or "them". In other words,,, Counting (them) has never pleased us.

updated Aug 13, 2013
edited by amaken
posted by amaken