Home
Q&A
Emotions in Subjunctive

Emotions in Subjunctive

3
votes

I'm trying to learn the subjunctive. It said emotions, how a person feels, is always in the subjunctive. I texted my step father, how to say "I regret (or I'm sorry) that I killed the deer" and he responded with "Siento (mucho) haber matado al ciervo." Does it not use the subjunctive because it's referring to a past event?... Or, I'm a little confused. Having a hard time looking it up. Thanks for your input!

Also, I didn't kill a deer.

1896 views
updated Jun 28, 2013
posted by Fiona_HierbaHelada
Thanks for asking this. I am working on the subjunctive lessons here on SD. I'm just hoping lots of repetition will help the penny drop. - Findy, Jun 27, 2013
Francobollo's answer is an excellent one. There is so much for English speakers to learn about the Subjunctive in Spanish, so plan on spending a lot of time on it. - Jubilado, Jun 27, 2013

2 Answers

2
votes

You could say: Siento mucho haber matado al ciervo or Siento mucho que yo haya matado al ciervo (but this last construction is awkward because yo is the subject of both the main and subordinate clauses). Hence, it is more elegant to use the perfect infinitive (haber matado).

However, if the subject is different in both clauses, the subjunctive would be perfect.

Siento mucho que Mario haya matado al ciervo.

Do not forget to introduce your subjunctive clauses with que.

updated Jun 27, 2013
posted by francobollo
1
vote

Franco is spot on and a good rule of thumb is that when there is no change of subject - for example in your sentence, the same person that is sorry is the one who killed the deer (allegedly jeje) then you just follow the emotion (declared in the indicative) with a verb in its infinitive form.

It's when one person feels and emotion about something that someone else did that you have the emotion described in the indicative mood and what the other person did in the subjunctive.

The reason for this is that the important thing is that some one is sharing how they feel, the thing that made them feel that way is likely already known information or is at least less important so it is relegated to the back seat as it were by the subjunctive mood.

updated Jun 28, 2013
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
So helpful!! Thank you. - Fiona_HierbaHelada, Jun 28, 2013
:) - Kiwi-Girl, Jun 28, 2013