Home
Q&A
OK, help me out here. Why if Spanish has so many verb conjugations, then do they it is efficient.

OK, help me out here. Why if Spanish has so many verb conjugations, then do they it is efficient.

3
votes

I've heard that Spanish is smooth and efficient language. If there are so many ways to conjugate a verb, how is that efficient. English does not seem to do this. I am going to pick a easy one. run = runner and ran. OK, try fly = flier, flying, and flew, flown. Buy = buying, buyer, bought.


The when I look at the conjugating list of Spanish verbs, I'm like oh man. I love this. Don't get me wrong. I wan't to speak Spanish for three very powerful reasons.

First, I am going to be a journalist. This is going to help me in one of many ways such as interviewing. Second, before long we will see half of the country speak Spanish. I do not want to be left behind. Third, jobs, jobs, jobs. Spanish will give us a leg up on the competition. Fourth, I happen to love the way Spanish sounds.

I just want to know why people told me would be easier than English? I do not see that. But it took me my entire life to learn English, and in many ways I am still nailing it down.

7861 views
updated Sep 17, 2016
posted by T_Bladel

13 Answers

3
votes

I guess it depends on what you mean by "efficient". In most cases, Spanish will take more words to express a concept than the English counterpart. However, I believe Spanish expresses shades of meaning, the subtleties that many times are left behind in English. There is no doubt that Spanish has a more complex verb structure.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by Noetol
Great answer. I did not think of it that way. Also, I did not realize the scope of the tenses. The idea that words can have a mood is awesome. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
2
votes

I am going to pick a easy one. run = runner and ran. OK, try fly = flier, flying, and flew, flown. Buy = buying, buyer, bought.

The first rule of any journalist: Know how to identify verbs, which do not include runner, flier, buyer. These are nouns.

I just want to know why people told me (Spanish) would be easier than English?

I have heard this too, but by people who can only use three basic tenses and have severely limited communication skills. An advanced level of Spanish is a completely story. English, in fact, is one of the most difficult languages to acquire as a second / third language.

updated Sep 17, 2016
posted by 005faa61
"I have heard this too, but FROM people who can only use three basic tenses". You may have heard it SAID BY them, but if you are just hearing,--FROM. - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
indicative, subjunctive, imperative, perfect and perfect subjunctive. This is my point, not whether runner is a noun. I wasn't really thinking about it when I made my list. I love how people can be so passive aggressive . I'm talking about all those, - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
I think maybe I should not of said that. I don't think, or hope, you were not trying to be passive aggressive. I was probably mad at my self for not recognizing that I put nouns on a verb list. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
That is just total non-sense to say English is "one of the most difficult languages to acquire". What really is going on is that English is one of the most learned langugages by the sheer number of people learning it. - ikihi, Sep 17, 2016
If many people are learning a language, the high number of people learning it creates the notion that the given language was hard to learn - ikihi, Sep 17, 2016
2
votes

All the romance languages have this - and other "problems".

Sometimes I think they were designed by a committee. ha ha

As for the subjunctive - that problem happens, in the main, because they do not have the 11 Modals - including would / could etc.

updated Jun 6, 2013
edited by ian-hill
posted by ian-hill
It is English that has essentially lost its subjunctive rather. Most United Statesians, be they formally educated or no, can't recognize a subjunctive in English, let alone understand it in another language - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
In fact, there are whole crowds of supposedly highly educated United Statesians among various professions, including teaching English, who will erroneously correct an English subjunctive. - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
English has N O T lost the subjunctive - and it is so much easier to know when to use it and construct it than Spanish. - ian-hill, Jun 6, 2013
Interesting word--"essentially". - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
And yet that Romance language committee did a much better job that our spelling committee ;) - rogspax, Jun 6, 2013
They sure did :) - ian-hill, Jun 6, 2013
That's exactly what I mean. The subjunctive is hardly used in English. The imperative is easy in English, but not so much in Spanish. Don't throw that, stand down.... That's easy. Additionally, there's a cultural difference involved. My point is... - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
those that said English is much harder to me may have been wrong. I am not sure yet. I do know that adding mood to a word is new to me. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
Not directly related but consider what happens in English when any verb is preceded with one of the 11 Modals = 11 new sentences wow! - ian-hill, Jun 6, 2013
I eat pizza - I can eat pizza - I could eat piza - I would eat pizza etc. etc 11 times. How about that for flexiblity and mood? - ian-hill, Jun 6, 2013
2
votes

I think the "Spanish is easy" thing is only relative. There are many languages that are much harder for a European-language speaker to pick up, but there is no truly "easy" language. Spanish just happens to be one of the less challenging languages in which to acquire good working communication skills. There are many languages with complex pronunciation systems, tones, non-phonetic writing systems, completely foreign (to us European language folks) word orders and other such complexities, of which Spanish has none. So in some ways, Spanish is a simpler language than many, including, I would say, English.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by PumpkinCalabaza
Exactamente. - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
Why do you think it is easier than English? Was English your first or second language? - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
First, but English (in my opinion) is a far more irregular and grammatically and phonetically complex language than Spanish. Of course, that's not to say that English is in any way better or worse than Spanish, They're just different. - PumpkinCalabaza, Jun 6, 2013
2
votes

As you write ... today's supercomputers are working on a "universal language for the world".

No irregular anything. No preterite and imperfect for one past tense. And most of all no masculine and feminine.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by readytodictate
Sí, se llaman dinero, Capitalismo y guerra sin fin o: "The World R Us". - EugenioCosta hace 16 minutos - EugenioCosta, Jun 6, 2013
2
votes

Efficient and easy are two different things. Anyone who says that Spanish is easy is overly optimistic at best. Spanish is what it is. I think it is a complex language but consistent in pronunciation. Your can embrace it and try to learn or move on. For me, I have a long way to go and I am not trying to rush to get there but rather trying to enjoy the journey.

updated Jun 6, 2013
edited by kirk1
posted by kirk1
If your "move on" comment was meant for my question, I'm not sure you got past the title since I clearly say I love the language, plus list four positive reasons for me to feel this way. My question revolves around the idea it's a perfect language. I - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
By the way, I enjoy all learning. I wanted to know what makes people say it's perfect, smooth or efficient. I can learn from legit answers. Thank you for trying. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
2
votes

Talking about "efficiency", I can say that the more complex Spanish verb system is more "efficient" than the English one, with its "effcient"subjunctive mood and simpler conditional tense, for example, it expresses clearly what you wanna say. Not so much in English which makes use of auxiliary verbs of the past forms of the verbs to do the same thing.

That's from the perspective of a ESL student.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by diagonx
Something I have told many former ESL students: Things like "wanna" are lazy English and should be avoided like the plague - 005faa61, Jun 6, 2013
I agree about "wanna" but in defense it's a cultural thing as well. The hip hop culture is changing American English. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
Brilliant. I guess waiting until I more clearly understood what all the tenses were for would have taken care of this question. HA! Thank you. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
1
vote

I guess it depends on what you mean by "efficient".

Well said. You´d have to define a metric. If it´s number of letters or words to express a given concept, then Spanish probably loses, just through the extra gender and and quanity endings and minimal use of compound words. Otoh, if one measures the time needed to learn to spell properly, or the time needed to correct spelling errors, then English comes up short. It´s really hard to compare languages as a whole. At best, doable over a fairly narrow context.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by rogspax
Good answer. I would have to agree. My problem is I know very little about the Spanish language. This is my third week in class. I know that English still obnubilates the best of us. I wonder if there will be a day that I don't have to translate Spanish. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
1
vote

Something I have told many former ESL students: Things like "wanna" are lazy English and should be avoided like the plague - JulianChivi

Why, yes; but it's been long since I've considered myself to be a "right" student.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by diagonx
Or "proper", should I say? - diagonx, Jun 6, 2013
What must be recognized is that native English speakers abuse their language more than natives of any other language, so be careful with the natives :- ) - 005faa61, Jun 6, 2013
Interesting. I think English has been changing for so many years that this new way of using English is actually going to become part of the speech. - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
1
vote

Un ejercicio: cuál es correcto:

(1) Toys R Us

(2) Toys B Us

(3) Both of the above.

(4) Neither of the above.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by EugenioCosta
Are you having a joke here? - ian-hill, Jun 6, 2013
2 - rogspax, Jun 6, 2013
1
vote

It is absurd to contrast and compare languages except in the context of X from the point of view of Y.

Thus, for instance, English is much easier for a speaker of, say, the Northern dialects of Chinese, than Chinese is for an English-speaker.

But to say why would take a long essay, and few unacquainted with both languages will follow.

If one runs into the statement, "Latin is easier than Greek", for example, notice that the unstated context is WHO is saying it--an English-speaker, for example. So the statement in full is: "[For an English-speaker] Latin is easier than Greek."

Beyond that, the most important qualification is what one might be talking about when one says "fluency".

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by EugenioCosta
Yes, what would one call fluent? - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
1
vote

thats whats hard for me tooo. i have finals next week and i suck at cinjugating

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by spainishdummy
All you can do is enjoy it. I have to do the whole class in five weeks. It takes work. I'm am using a combo of my textbook, this site, ask.com, and a awesome self-taught class from ITunes called "Arkansas" Spanish 1 - T_Bladel, Jun 6, 2013
0
votes

A shopkeeper puts up a simple sign--"Toys". He may even make some of his goods himself. A vast corporate venture puts up a sign, in countless venues, that looks simple-minded, "We R Toys" but makes megalomaniac claims. And those quite beyond the obvious Pinocchioisms involved, themselves a working part of the hypnosis.

updated Jun 6, 2013
posted by EugenioCosta