Personal or prepositional "a" here?
La psicóloga le pregunta a ella qué ve.
Is the "a" prepositional or personal in this sentence?
P.S. I get very confused sometimes with "a". On the one hand, instructions I´ve read say to add a prepositional phrase to sentences with ambiguous indirect objects (as applies here). On the other hand, a personal "a" is to be used between verbs and people (as well as other circumstances). So, when I look at a sentence, I can´t tell which is being used and, therefore, have a hard time knowing how to use them properly myself.
Edit: Chileno, in English, what is being said is, "The (female) psychologist is asking her what she sees." The photograph (from my language computer software) that is associated with this sentence shows a psychologist administering a Rorschach test to a patient.
2 Answers
The words "a ella" are added in the sentence to make it clear that the psychiatrist is talking to a female patient. The indirect pronoun "le" can mean to him or to her.
The word "a" is prepositional because this is not a case of using it in front of a person (noun) which is a direct object of the verb. And in this case it really means to her.
I don't know because I don't know my own grammar.
I can tell though That it means "the (female) psychologist asked (to) her what does she see.
Can you explain that one in your (English) grammar?
Thank you.
![]()