Home
Q&A
Personal or prepositional "a" here?

Personal or prepositional "a" here?

1
vote

La psicóloga le pregunta a ella qué ve.

Is the "a" prepositional or personal in this sentence?

P.S. I get very confused sometimes with "a". On the one hand, instructions I´ve read say to add a prepositional phrase to sentences with ambiguous indirect objects (as applies here). On the other hand, a personal "a" is to be used between verbs and people (as well as other circumstances). So, when I look at a sentence, I can´t tell which is being used and, therefore, have a hard time knowing how to use them properly myself.

Edit: Chileno, in English, what is being said is, "The (female) psychologist is asking her what she sees." The photograph (from my language computer software) that is associated with this sentence shows a psychologist administering a Rorschach test to a patient.

1210 views
updated May 16, 2013
edited by Trieltor
posted by Trieltor

2 Answers

2
votes

The words "a ella" are added in the sentence to make it clear that the psychiatrist is talking to a female patient. The indirect pronoun "le" can mean to him or to her.

The word "a" is prepositional because this is not a case of using it in front of a person (noun) which is a direct object of the verb. And in this case it really means to her.

updated May 16, 2013
posted by Jubilado
Thank you Jubilado. I think that my main confusion is not understanding that prepositional phrases themselves can serve as direct objects. - Trieltor, May 16, 2013
1
vote

I don't know because I don't know my own grammar.

I can tell though That it means "the (female) psychologist asked (to) her what does she see.

Can you explain that one in your (English) grammar?

Thank you.

wink

updated May 27, 2013
edited by chileno
posted by chileno
Yes. Please look at the edit to the original post. - Trieltor, May 16, 2013