Home
Q&A
Hay que vs. Ay, qué

Hay que vs. Ay, qué

1
vote

I was listening to this song called "Grosero" and the first line in the song sounds like "Hay que grosero." The translation of this didn't make much sense to me, so I looked up the lyrics but every site read "Hay que grosero." Is it possible that she's saying "Ay, qué grosero" or does "hay que grosero" mean something? Here is a link to the full lyrics if it helps.

1471 views
updated Apr 10, 2013
edited by lizarey
posted by lizarey

4 Answers

1
vote

¡Ay, qué grosero! is the right answer. It means "Oh, how rude". Hay que grosero does not make sense.

You can say: Hay hombres que son groseros. But that's a totally different construction.

updated Apr 10, 2013
posted by francobollo
Gracias - lizarey, Apr 10, 2013
1
vote

"Hay que" is a very common structure but in completely different contexts, ie: "Hay que pagar la cuenta" ...... "the bill must be paid" and has nothing to do with the explanitive expression "Ay qué ...."

You have come across one of many internet misspellings.

updated Apr 10, 2013
posted by 005faa61
Gracias - lizarey, Apr 10, 2013
0
votes

Hay is a conjugation of haber, the way you put it here, hay que, is an impersonal construction that denotes duty or need of doing something:

  • Hay que tomar agua después de ejercitarse

  • Habrá que esperar hasta mañana para saber.

  • Había que actuar rápidamente para evitarlo.

Ay is an interjection, it is used very broadly

updated Apr 10, 2013
posted by diagonx
0
votes

hay que

deber que

y

tener que

casi lo mismo

you must do it, have to do it

updated Apr 10, 2013
posted by readytodictate