Home
Q&A
What difference does 'sí' make here?

What difference does 'sí' make here?

3
votes

"Pero ella sí fue al día siguiente"

How different is it from this: Pero ella fue al día siguiente

What does 'sí' mean there?

972 views
updated Mar 19, 2013
posted by turoko
Really - did. - ian-hill, Mar 19, 2013
In the first sentence it means(But if she went............)and in the second(But she went...........)hoped that helped:) - Vitorine, Mar 19, 2013
Sorry, but careful on this one, Vitorine. Si with no accent means “if”; sí with an accent means “yes.” Here, it’s the “emphatic yes,” like the “emphatic do” in English. - brian5764, Mar 19, 2013

4 Answers

4
votes

"Pero ella sí fue al día siguiente"

"But she DID go the next day"

It's stressing.

updated Mar 20, 2013
posted by RodrigoM
3
votes

I agree with the others.

I also wanted to share that it may be helpful for you to read it as 'indeed' in situations like these. It helps me, and if it helps you that's great, but if it doesn't then that's fine, too. Whatever works for you! :p

Pero ella sí fue al día siguiente.

But she indeed went the following day!

updated Mar 20, 2013
posted by modrak
Well I don’t know about Turoko or Rodrigo, but it works for me. Good point. Isn’t it interesting how it’s “indeed went” but not “did went”? - brian5764, Mar 19, 2013
3
votes

Hi Turoko.

The word sí is sometimes used to mean what we call the emphatic do in English. (As opposed to an occurrence of a main verb do or the bizarre feature that English has of using do/does/did to ask questions or negate statements.)

Examples of the emphatic do:

I do understand this now.

I did remember to turn off the light.

So, then:

Pero ella sí fue al día siguiente = But she did go the following day.

It’s emphatic in the past tense, as opposed to merely saying, “But she went the following day.”

updated Mar 20, 2013
edited by brian5764
posted by brian5764
1
vote

Sí entiendo.. I do understand

updated Mar 20, 2013
posted by gohern