Home
Q&A
imperfect subjunctive question for you

imperfect subjunctive question for you

3
votes

I was watching a story about the creation in spanish and I sentence read: Si comieres de ese árbol ciertamente morirás.

Why is comer is subjuntive? And also, why is it in imperfect?

I would have said" Si comes de ese árbol ciertamente morirás.

824 views
updated Jan 11, 2013
posted by kyle_hurley

1 Answer

1
vote

Hello, kyle!

comieres is not imperfect, but the old, obsolete future subjunctive, which is no longer used.

So your sentence is perfect with "comes", and the one you've come across sounds like olde Spanish.

updated Jan 11, 2013
posted by cogumela
Ese futuro del subjuntivo como se ha quedado en frases de antaño, Cogu. - francobollo, Jan 11, 2013