Home
Q&A
Pluscuamperfecto VS condicional perfecto

Pluscuamperfecto VS condicional perfecto

3
votes

Can someone explain the real difference between pluscuamperfecto and condicional perfecto?

Ex: Lo detuvieron porque había cometido tres asaltos

VS

Ex: Sabía que lo habrían detenido para el día siguiente.

From what I can gather, the difference is that in Pluperfect, both the actions happened in the past and there was no uncertainty. And in condicional perfect, both the actions happened in the past but there was an element of uncertainty present.

Help!!

9485 views
updated Dec 12, 2012
posted by peterslj
Hello, welcome to the forum! - rac1, Dec 11, 2012

2 Answers

2
votes

The conditional perfect is not really a matter of uncertainty. It is more a comparison: one action is conditional upon another. In your example, the detention for the next day had to be triggered by something. I knew they would have retained him for the next day if... or because... The sentence would need that sort of context either within the sentence or within the context of another sentence or paragraph.

The pluscuamperfecto (pluperfect) defines the order of two events in the past. He was detained because he had previously commited three assaults. One event leads to the other.

Check these links : conditional perfect

past perfect

updated Dec 12, 2012
edited by Noetol
posted by Noetol
A medal! - annierats, Dec 12, 2012
Thanks, Annie! - Noetol, Dec 12, 2012
1
vote

Check out these two links: link1 and link2

updated Dec 11, 2012
posted by francobollo
I'm learning following you around.! - rac1, Dec 11, 2012
Follow away, amiga. That's the whole point: I follow you, you follow me... lol - francobollo, Dec 11, 2012
Is the example really plucuamperfecto subjunctivo? - Noetol, Dec 11, 2012