Home
Q&A
En ese momento mi abuelo enfermó cada día peor.

En ese momento mi abuelo enfermó cada día peor.

1
vote

En ese momento mi abuelo enfermó cada día peor.

La enfermedad de mi abuelo estaba cada día grave.

La enermedad de mi abuelo era cada día más grave.

I made the first sentence. The second and the third is from another two books. I wonder if my answer is ok too?

935 views
updated Nov 20, 2012
posted by zhmelissa
Maybe you could tellus what you mean, in English, exactly? Do you mean: Just then, he started to get worse? - annierats, Nov 19, 2012
At that time, my grandfather is getting sicker and sicker everyday. - zhmelissa, Nov 20, 2012
..was getting sicker.. - annierats, Nov 20, 2012

3 Answers

2
votes

Yes, the original in some language would help.

Are you trying to say

At that time, my grandfather was getting worse (more sick) every day.

In any event, I´m not sure that using the preterite ´enfermó´ which is a pretty specific point in time, is a good with with cada día, which is an unspecified period of time, which could maybe better be expressed with the imperfect, such as in annierats suggestion.

I´d like to hear a native chime in on that. I´m still trying to improve on preterite vs imperfect

updated Nov 20, 2012
posted by rogspax
Muchas gracias. - zhmelissa, Nov 20, 2012
That's what I thought too, Rog. Good observation. - annierats, Nov 20, 2012
2
votes

The third is correct ; La enfermedad (enermedad) de mi abuelo era cada día más grave.

updated Nov 20, 2012
posted by maquen
Gracias Maquen! - rac1, Nov 20, 2012
Yes, the second one doesn't work, to my mind, evenif it comes from a book. - annierats, Nov 20, 2012
2
votes

Mi abuelo estaba emporeando cada día. My grandfather got worse every day.

Is that any help?

updated Nov 20, 2012
edited by annierats
posted by annierats
Thanks. - zhmelissa, Nov 20, 2012