Home
Q&A
Practice: "Should Olympic Athletes be banned for questionable actions?

Practice: "Should Olympic Athletes be banned for questionable actions?

5
votes

Do you think that these men should be banned from swimming at the

"London Olympics " this year ? It is not the first foolish action that

these guys have undertaken , but that has no bearing on this case .

Do you think that our "Olympians " should be of exemplary character ?

After all they are the " images" of our respective countries , and perhaps

we are all judged by the actions of a few .


Bob Katter says Australia's "thought police have gone too far" in pillorying our Olympic swimmers for being pictured with legal firearms.

Mr Katter, the member for Kennedy, stepped in to defend controversial Sunshine Coast swimmer Nick D'Arcy saying political correctness has gone too far when men have to "apologise for being men", reports The North West Star.

Mr Katter took aim at the "thought police" for the criticism of D'Arcy and fellow Olympian Kenrick Monk, after the pair were criticised when Monk posted a photo on Facebook of the pair branding firearms in a United States gun shop.

enter image description here

1865 views
updated Jul 7, 2012
edited by --Mariana--
posted by ray76
I've seen dozens of photos of American and Australian 'heroes' alike, some in history books and childrens' books. Should we ban books depicting photos of American folk heroes like Davey Crocket, or Mexico's Santana, or civil war heroes, etc.? - 0095ca4c, Jun 11, 2012
Maybe photos of our fighting men during all the wars should be banned. Why stop there? Why not rewrite history books without any photos at all? - 0095ca4c, Jun 11, 2012
Changed your category to "Practice." We need to have interesting posts like this, but practice our Spanish/English at the same time. - --Mariana--, Jun 11, 2012
Thank you Mariana , i was not too sure about that one . That is exactly what i was hoping to do , i think this one is working. - ray76, Jun 11, 2012

4 Answers

2
votes

Well, I look at it this way, if the Olympic committee and anyone else thinks that this particular photo is depicting bad behavior, then they should ban all firearm sports from Olympic events. No more shooting events at all!

Ban the tri sports!

Ban skeet shooting while you are at it.

Heck why don't we ban swimming? Some of those guys look ridiculous in their speedos and someone might take an innaproriate photograph!

updated Jul 7, 2012
posted by 0095ca4c
Hahaha! - --Mariana--, Jun 11, 2012
Most of the swimmers can be mighty embarrassing , in a nice kind of way. - ray76, Jun 11, 2012
1
vote

I don't think that these guys are behaving badly. It's not as though they are holding up a confederate flag.


No creo que esos tipos comportarse mal. No es como mostrando una bandera confederada.

updated Jun 11, 2012
posted by --Mariana--
Great comment , there are worse things that they could be doing. - ray76, Jun 11, 2012
Like packing their Louis Vuitton suitcase for the return trip home from London?? - 0095ca4c, Jun 11, 2012
1
vote

I personally believe that we have had enough making excuses for men behaving badly.

At least some men should be able to demonstrate integrity, good judgement and decency. This is what true leadership is all about.

I don't know what the Olympic committee's position is on olympiad behavior, but I would support them being explicit about expected behavior and then holding the athletes to that standard. If there is not an explicit behavior articulated, then it is inappropriate to discipline these men. Having no expectations articulated, people will generally sink to the lowest common denominator.

updated Jun 11, 2012
posted by JoyceM
Tend to agree Joyce , once our values slip there is no stopping the drift to anarchy. - ray76, Jun 11, 2012
I just don't see how that photo is depicting bad behavior. - 0095ca4c, Jun 11, 2012
I agree, they have to make some "standards of conduct" rules. - --Mariana--, Jun 11, 2012
0
votes

This is another comment by the member for Kennedy , Bob Katter"

enter image description here

Will they finally be happy when men can only be photographed at a day spa carrying their designer chihuahua in a designer Louis Vuitton doggy handbag?


There is a strong point here, if one photograph is unacceptable , then why is

the other not of equal value ? I would like your opinions on this vexing issue .

updated Jun 11, 2012
posted by ray76
He does have a point here. If one photograph is that upsetting to some, maybe they should not show olympic athletes doing anything in their 'off time' so as not to upset anyone. One man's honey is another man's poison. - 0095ca4c, Jun 11, 2012
He is from far north Queensland , it is very much like Texas . - ray76, Jun 11, 2012
Which happens to be in the opposite direction, ie, far south. - Eddy, Jun 11, 2012
You are so right Eddy. In fact far north Queensland is known as " The Deep North " . - ray76, Jun 11, 2012