Home
Q&A
Imperfect Subjunctive or not?

Imperfect Subjunctive or not?

2
votes

"Les digo que (hablar) un poco de español durante el verano"

What form of hablar would you use here? Present Subjunctive, Future, Conditional, Imperfect Subjunctive, or Preterit/Imperfect?

1108 views
updated Jun 8, 2012
posted by JessiBrink
It depends what you want to say..Future or imperfect sems most likely to me.. - annierats, Jun 8, 2012
Yes, without more context, this is hard to answer. - Noetol, Jun 8, 2012

2 Answers

3
votes

Les digo que hablen un poco de español durante el verano. I tell them to talk a bit in Spanish during the summer.

I presume you are telling a third party about what you tell your students to do. You have no guarantee that they do this. Indeed if you have been teaching long you likely have strong doubts that many will practice any of their academic subjects over the summer.

Because of these three things I suggest present subjunctive:

  • Two idependent clauses joined by que
  • Different subject in each clause
  • Presence of uncertainty

If I changed the first verb to the past tense (I told them) then I would use the past subjunctive: Les dije que hablaran un poco de español durante el verano.

updated Jun 8, 2012
posted by lachelvi
Grand explanation. Thank you lachelvi! - 0095ca4c, Jun 8, 2012
Thanks for both putting in context and explaining the answer. Good post! :)) - Noetol, Jun 8, 2012
Yes, excellent! - annierats, Jun 8, 2012
0
votes

Thank you lachelvi, I thought she wanted to tell the third party she had spoken or would speak Spanish during the summer to come , or possibly last summer. You've sorted us out!

updated Jun 8, 2012
edited by annierats
posted by annierats