Home
Q&A
Does "Los ninos hayan en ti su refugio" make sense?

Does "Los ninos hayan en ti su refugio" make sense?

2
votes

Looking at song lyrics in Spanish for a praise song, this line stood out as making no sense. I think the translator thought that "haber" (to have [auxillary verb]) meant "tener" (to have). Am I right in thinking this or does "Los ninos hayan en ti su refugio" make sense?

1278 views
updated Jun 6, 2012
posted by pianoviola
Wait a bit and you will get more answers. I feel fairly confident, however. - annierats, Jun 3, 2012
Thank you :) - pianoviola, Jun 3, 2012
De nada. Thank you, you made me go and look the song up! - annierats, Jun 3, 2012

4 Answers

4
votes

It should be hallan from hallar, not hayan from haber.

updated Sep 15, 2012
edited by murkilator
posted by murkilator
You're right, thanks! - annierats, Jun 4, 2012
3
votes

I agree with murkitalor. In the lyrics of the song there is a mistake. It should say los niños hallan en ti su refugio (the children find their shelter in you). Hallar = encontrar (to find).

updated Sep 15, 2012
posted by Juliss
I almost forgot, the pronunciation of both words are the same. - Juliss, Jun 3, 2012
2
votes

The children take shelter with you,

The children make you their haven..

Neither is an exact translation.

updated Jun 4, 2012
posted by annierats
So are you saying the "hayan" has a legit purpose? - pianoviola, Jun 3, 2012
It's the only verb in the sentence. Literally, they may have, the subjunctive of hay, which means there is. - annierats, Jun 3, 2012
Literal translation: The children may have in you their shelter.. - annierats, Jun 3, 2012
Would you prefer to say "Los ninos tienen en ti su refugio"? - pianoviola, Jun 3, 2012
I looked up the son, it says ' hayan'. If you go for tener, maybe it should be tengan, but, it's a song, stick with the native original. - annierats, Jun 3, 2012
Marco Barrientos: Nadie es como tú. Stick with the original! - annierats, Jun 3, 2012
Indeed, the original says hallan.. Sorry about this answer, I did my best. - annierats, Jun 4, 2012
Nice detective work, people! - RedLine55, Jun 4, 2012
1
vote

Tu misericordia es como un río

tus manos traen sanidad

los niños hallan en ti su refugio.

There you are. Murkildor is right. Further search confirmed it. I can't say I even like the song but I've done a good lot of finding out for you!

updated Sep 15, 2012
edited by annierats
posted by annierats