Home
Q&A
Ser, Estar, el Pretérito, y el Imperfecto.

Ser, Estar, el Pretérito, y el Imperfecto.

2
votes

Hoy en mi examen de español había una pregunta que dice : Mientras veíamos la película, alguen llegó a la puerta (llegó was a fill in the blank which i completed correctly) entonces se escirbe: _______ un estudiante nuevo. I filled in fue, but the answer key said era. I kept using el pretérito because of llegó in the sentence before.

Could someone explain to me why using the imperfect is correct in this context? ¡Muchas Gracias!

2677 views
updated Mar 29, 2012
posted by casebeth1209

3 Answers

2
votes

Llegó was used because preterite is used for a past action that interrupts one that had been ongoing. The person entering interrupted the action of watching a movie.

And Noetol is right--the person who entered was a student, ongoing. It was part of their nature, their being, so it would be imperfect.

updated Mar 29, 2012
posted by missy8888
4
votes

Just to conjecture here, llegó was proper because it referred to a specifically defined action in the past. Era referrs to the student himself - he was a student before and after he came to the door, a continuous description with no defined beginning or end.

Only my take on it.

updated Mar 29, 2012
posted by Noetol
nice :) - Kiwi-Girl, Mar 28, 2012
I like your style. - Ox-Y-Gen, Mar 28, 2012
Thanks, Carson! - Noetol, Mar 28, 2012
Thanks, Kiwi! - Noetol, Mar 28, 2012
:) - Kiwi-Girl, Mar 28, 2012
2
votes

As Noetol pointed out the preterite is good for completed past actions, the person being the new student however was not an action but a description so ser/imp is the one to use smile

updated Mar 29, 2012
edited by Kiwi-Girl
posted by Kiwi-Girl
great thanks! I always get confused which one to use for descriptions - casebeth1209, Mar 29, 2012