Home
Q&A
" Cada nueva idea " Translation exercise, Spanish .

" Cada nueva idea " Translation exercise, Spanish .

5
votes

Cada nueva idea es una imposibilidad hasta que nace .

Each new idea is an impossibility until it is born.

Traducción , ayuda por favor.

I think that " born " is wrong here it needs to be expanded upon.

2092 views
updated Feb 27, 2012
edited by ray76
posted by ray76
"hasta que nace" ;) - Cordobesa, Feb 26, 2012
Oh dear that was bad sorry Cordobesa, and thank you . - ray76, Feb 26, 2012
Es un placer :) - Cordobesa, Feb 26, 2012

7 Answers

5
votes

Creo que vuestras respuestas son perfectas, Ray y Xoco, así que cambiaré un poquito la frase:

"Toda nueva idea es inviable hasta que se origina/hasta que aparece"

o, mejor: "Toda nueva idea es inviable hasta que se extiende/se propaga" smile

updated Feb 26, 2012
edited by Cordobesa
posted by Cordobesa
: ) - Fidalgo, Feb 26, 2012
5
votes

born, created, hatched

Some ideas:

Cada nueva idea es una imposibilidad a menos que nazca.

Each new idea is an impossibility unless it is born.

Cada nueva idea es una imposibilidad hasta que es creada.

Each new idea is an impossibility until it is created.

updated Feb 27, 2012
edited by Xocoyote
posted by Xocoyote
Good thinking mate , but many great ideas wither on the bough they need to be born into fruition. - ray76, Feb 26, 2012
"a menos que nazca", "es creada" :) - Cordobesa, Feb 26, 2012
: ) - Fidalgo, Feb 26, 2012
Gracias Cordobesa! - Xocoyote, Feb 26, 2012
De nada, Xocoyote ;) - Cordobesa, Feb 27, 2012
3
votes

Ray, is this a quote?? I have heard this before somewhere, and I think it is correctly translated as you have it, and I agree that the idea is poorly worded. Ideas, unlike people and puppies, are not conceived or born. They almost never arrive fully formed, but are worked out, refined and tested over a period of time. And I have never heard of an idea that was patently not possible - how do you prove that it isn't possible? enter image description here

updated Feb 27, 2012
posted by Lector_Constante
It is a quote but not quite original . Maybe when it was first written the times were different and we expressed ourselves in another way which does not fit so well with us today. - ray76, Feb 27, 2012
3
votes

Pretty much, dear Ray. This is only my humble interpretation, you understand. I think the thrust of the original statement was more like an encouragement to people to act on their ideas (assuming they were positive and not negative to others), because it would take those ideas out of the realm of mere possibility and put them into play. Other than that, I don't have the mental acuity to understand much of philosophy or physics.

Cordobesa, thank you so much for your better translation of my words. Much appreciated. And thank you, Ray, for such an intriguing comment. It certainly makes one use thinking skills.

updated Feb 26, 2012
posted by NancyGrace
De nada, Nancy :) - Cordobesa, Feb 26, 2012
2
votes

You fellows are all totally brilliant. Your thoughts are encompassing very sophisticated philosophical arguments, and they are great fun to read and very thought provoking.

My thought is an idea is created at conception. Therefore, might it be reasonable to suggest as a final phrase: . . . hasta que sea puesto in la acción?

updated Feb 26, 2012
posted by NancyGrace
"hasta que se pone en acción/en marcha" - Cordobesa, Feb 26, 2012
So you are saying that thoughts are merely atoms of energy and are only formed and become reality when they are activated and become the possibility of having substance . - ray76, Feb 26, 2012
In other words like a Karmic reaction , the thought creates the action . - ray76, Feb 26, 2012
Germ of an idea, birth of an invention? The concept versus its embodiment/application?? - Lector_Constante, Feb 26, 2012
2
votes

But we have to ask , when was an idea created , at conception or at birth ?

updated Feb 26, 2012
posted by ray76
And, I must ask in return, which came first, the creation of an idea, or the idea of creation? ;) - ciscocaja, Feb 26, 2012
Next time i am talking with Stephen Hawking I shall ask him, but if you are talking of " creativity " well then that came out of the mind . - ray76, Feb 26, 2012
Definitions first: what is conception? what is birth? --- of ideas, not mammals. - Lector_Constante, Feb 26, 2012
1
vote

I believe that ideas, like life itself, begin at conception. Because it is at that point that all of the raw material is available for it it grow and become what it will be in its final form. However, ideas are not constrained by physical DNA, so they are allowed to permutate and evolve into a form not predictable at conception. But that just points out the limitations of a physical body, and not that of the soul.

That being said, as an answer to the first question, I think that the intent would certainly be understood whether nazca, creada, o se pone en acción.

updated Feb 27, 2012
posted by Echoline