Home
Q&A
quien and que, which one to use?

quien and que, which one to use?

0
votes

In the following sentence:

La mujer ________(que/quien) vimos ayer, es la mujer de Juan.

I chose "quien", although I thought both would be fine according to the explanation in the reference section of SD.

However, the answer sheet says to use "que" with the following explanation:

“Quien” no puede ser sujeto de una oración especificativa.

Is the answer sheet correct? If so, why?

2857 views
updated Jan 25, 2012
posted by JazSpanish

3 Answers

1
vote

I think "que" is correct.

To use "quien", it should be slightly different: "La mujer a quien vimos ayer, es la mujer de Juan".

updated Jan 25, 2012
posted by 00e657d4
0
votes

I would always say "La mujer que vimos" in conversation if I were speaking to someone. That's just my personal preference. smile

In English you could say "The woman that we saw was Maria" or "The woman who we saw was Maria".

updated Jan 25, 2012
posted by Paralyse
0
votes

This is the difference between "who" and "whom". Who would be proper for this sentence, not whom. This is true for both Spanish and English.

You would not say, "The woman whom we saw yesterday..."

You would say, "The woman who we saw yesterday..."

updated Jan 25, 2012
posted by kdrinning