Home
Q&A
It was used - Fue / era / estaba?

It was used - Fue / era / estaba?

4
votes

Hey guys!

The other day I wanted to say that something was used when I bought it. I have seen "fue", "era" and "estaba"...

My friend said that I should use "fue", but I am wondering now if the other ones are wrong... or perhaps do they change the meaning slightly?

Fue / era / estaba usado cuando lo compré.

Thank you! smile

4484 views
updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by NikkiLR

6 Answers

6
votes

Well, the normal sentence would be: Estaba usado cuando lo compré.

If you say fue usado cuando lo compré it means that is was actually being used when you bought it, "era usado" doesn't sound quite normal to me but in any case it would mean the same as the first one.

updated Jan 20, 2012
posted by Dakie
Thanks =) My friend from Colombia just told me the same. - NikkiLR, Jan 19, 2012
1
vote

This is what I'm thinking: not at all infallible wink

fue usado, passive (it was used for cutting the cake kind of thing),

but estaba usado, state (it was used) - because the man had cut his sandwich with it, it was used

and then you could have 'era' if you are describing a characteristic instead of a state, The one I bought was a used one.

updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by Kiwi-Girl
1
vote

I think era usado is the best selection.


This is from about.com Ser is used

With adjectives to indicate inherent, innate or essential characteristics: This typically means to describe the essential nature of something, not how something might be at a particular moment.

Era usado cuando lo compré. It was used when I bought it.

updated Jan 19, 2012
edited by gringojrf
posted by gringojrf
Interesting... thank you! - NikkiLR, Jan 19, 2012
1
vote

Es de segunda mano.

updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by annierats
0
votes
updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by lorenzo9
0
votes

I think that "era un usado" it's better; it means "it's a used one"; because the "used" is not about using it, but the fact that you bought it second hand.

updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by Derpina