Home
Q&A
Are these two examples of "noun phrases"?

Are these two examples of "noun phrases"?

2
votes

If so, I am having trouble understanding the use of the articles "el and la". If not, I'm still having trouble understanding the article usage in this passage. I have 'bolded' the article in question.

In the NVI bible, Romans 13:8 reads like this: No tengan deudas pendientes con nadie, a no ser la de amarse unos a otros.

In the Reina Valera it reads like this: No debáis a nadie nada, sino el amaros unos a otros; porque el que ama al prójimo, ha cumplido la ley.

Aren't the phrases "de amarse unos a otros" and "amaros unos a otros" being treated as nouns? If so, why is one article feminine and the other masculine?

"a no ser la de amarse unos a otros" = unless the loving one another

"sino el amaros unos a otros" = but the you love one another.

Can you help me understand those two articles la and el?

Gracias

2102 views
updated Jan 10, 2012
edited by Jack-OBrien
posted by Jack-OBrien
jack, I'm just hesitantly trying to help, interesting to see more knowledgable answers. - annierats, Jan 10, 2012
and I appreciate it very much! - Jack-OBrien, Jan 10, 2012
Maybe you will get more help if you re-phrase the question, there are always lots of very basic questions about el and la, the better brains may not notice that this is a different question from the run of the mill. It needs a skilled interpreter! - annierats, Jan 10, 2012
Good move! Better heading, wait and see. - annierats, Jan 10, 2012

1 Answer

0
votes

I think the first one refers back to ''la duda''.

The second one I read as 'he who..'one who''

I'm not familiar with the text and thsi is only a suggestion, probably wrong.

updated Jan 10, 2012
posted by annierats
Actually, I think you're right. "La deuda" is the first one certainly but it is not a noun. I think the second one, "el amaros....." is being used as a noun. - Jack-OBrien, Jan 10, 2012
That's the trouble I get into when I'm looking at multiple translations.... - Jack-OBrien, Jan 10, 2012
I shouldn't have said "la deuda" but just "la". La is "la deuda". - Jack-OBrien, Jan 10, 2012
Yes, I see, that renders my interpretation useless, sorry. - annierats, Jan 10, 2012