Home
Q&A
A day without Internet

A day without Internet

10
votes

In order to protest the proposed US regulation known as SOPA The following websites will close down for 24 hours on January 23ed:

Google

Yahoo!

Facebook

Foursquare

Twitter

Wikipedia

Amazon

Mozilla

AOL

eBay

PayPal

IAC

LinkedIn

OpenDNS

Zynga

Source + explination of what SOPA is in Spanish: http://tecnologia.univision.mobi/content.html?nafurl=http://feedsyn.univision.com/contentXml?cid=824058&contentType=article&partner=mia

Wikipedia SOPA page

I really hope it doesn't include all goggle services... although I guess I can live a day without Gmail.. The list of sites is sure to grow. I would take down my web for the day page if I thought anyone ever visited it ever heh.

Will this affect you?

Do you think the internet should change?

Could you live without internet?

3156 views
updated Jan 19, 2012
edited by rabbitwho
posted by rabbitwho
rabbitwho - can you tell us what SOPA is in an (English) nutshell? - nonombre, Jan 6, 2012
I originally had a link, and then i realized the nutshell was far too small! Basically under the umbrella of protecting copyright the government wants to have an off switch for the internet that will allow them to shut down any page at any time - rabbitwho, Jan 6, 2012
for any reason without giving any reason and without giving the owners of the site a chance to defend themselves or remove whatever it was the government found issue with - rabbitwho, Jan 6, 2012
I'm pretty sure I couldn't live without internet...jeje - 001a2987, Jan 7, 2012
Chris, I am sure that as long as you have someone to speak Spanish with for 24 hours you will be fine. - Yeser007, Jan 7, 2012
I hope this doesn't get passed. Shutting down websites without notification or trial?! Where did you get the list of sites in the blackout? - Jadey7, Jan 9, 2012
jaja - you're right Gary..... :) - 001a2987, Jan 9, 2012

13 Answers

6
votes

Here is a link to a site that explains what SOPA is and what will happen if it is passed.

I will be missing all those sites if they do shut down that day, but I think the protest is a good thing. The government is trying to censor the internet! >.<

I don't think anything should change. Everything is fine just the way it is.

No, I could not live without the internet! :D

updated Feb 18, 2012
posted by NikkiLR
Agreed, one day to understand the destruction this will cause is better than entering into it blindly and irrevocably. - Stadt, Jan 7, 2012
5
votes

I'm afraid that even though I don't like the occupy movement one bit, this could be an excuse to shut down websites that allow users to organize themselves. The internet is a huge tool for social change as we've seen in the east it can really help to change things. I think world governments are afraid. Imagine on youtube you have a video like the one that came out recently of the police officers planting evidence, or the film of an army helicopter shooting civilians known as "collateral murder" imagine on the same website you have an unauthorized Lady Gaga video...

Maybe I'm paranoid, but I don't see why the entire site should be shut down over one infringement unless...

A news analysis in the information technology magazine eWeek stated, "The language of SOPA is so broad, the rules so unconnected to the reality of Internet technology and the penalties so disconnected from the alleged crimes that this bill could effectively kill e-commerce or even normal Internet use. The bill also has grave implications for existing U.S., foreign and international laws and is sure to spend decades in court challenges."

If one person uploaded one picture of Simba the lion king to twitter (twitpic) then twitter could be shut down indefinitely rather than the system as it is now, where twitter are contacted and asked to remove the picture. Same with Spanishdict, Ebay, Amazon etc.

updated Jan 18, 2012
posted by rabbitwho
4
votes

What about websites run in other countries? Can the US touch them? Because it seems a bit unfair if they can. I know most of the big ones are US based, but I don't think one organization should have control over the entire internet.

Also someone mention copyright issues on Twitter. A site that exists for user contributions is going to have a copyright issue somewhere (it's inevitable, think about how many people on facebook must have been tagged in a photo that contains copyrighted material). Does SOPA give them a stranglehold over these sites, to turn them off when they feel like it?

I wonder how much of the Internet the people who make this bill understand. The thought that we may be seeing the end of the Internet's golden age is a sad one.

updated Feb 18, 2012
posted by Hyena27
If congress has as much understanding as they demonstrate in the regulations that they pass that affect me- it is completely clear that they do not understand what they regulate at all, and are completely capable of destroying things with results..... - Stadt, Jan 7, 2012
...that anyone but they seem to be able to anticipate. :-( - Stadt, Jan 7, 2012
Right, that's exactly why everyone is so worried, even search engines have a certain amount of user generated content, look at google images! - rabbitwho, Jan 7, 2012
Lately the U.S. has been trying to pass legislation which regulates banks, internet, medical practices, online purchases, and many other sovereign institutions in foreign countries. - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
4
votes

To answer your questions rabbitwho....


1 - Don't know (yet)


2 - I think change is inevitable, especially with something like the 'net.


3 - Well, there was a time in the long ago past that I did survive without the 'net. But without the net there'd be no Spanishdict. I'd live but I'd be very sad indeed


(I've just had the most horrible thought - I'd have to go back to actually doing housework and cooking and such like shock

updated Jan 13, 2012
edited by nonombre
posted by nonombre
The thing about SOPA is that it doesn't allow for any kind of "fair use" whatsoever. SpanishDict could be shut down just because of my Avatar, let alone the pictures in the WotD threads! - rabbitwho, Jan 6, 2012
:O That is a horrible thought - SonrisaDelSol, Jan 6, 2012
Too awful to even comtemplate Sonrisa jejeje - nonombre, Jan 6, 2012
It's not than just having the 'net, it's about not having free speech. How long 'till they regulate what tv and books can do too? - Jadey7, Jan 9, 2012
True, SpanishDict would be irrevocably hard hit by this legislation. - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
3
votes

What a horrible thought! I don't have television and it's winter here. I do have a lot of other things to catch up on. Hey rabbit. I'd like to know where your blog is. I'll go visit it. Gracias por la información.

updated Jan 9, 2012
posted by sanlee
I don't really have a blog, nothing about SOPA on it anyway. I tweet a bit and I'm kind of spread over a bunch of websites but I've links to most of them here: https://sites.google.com/site/rabbitwhohops/ - rabbitwho, Jan 7, 2012
3
votes

I guess I'll have to go back to reading a book in the bath...

updated Jan 9, 2012
posted by annierats
just so long as it's not an ebook! - rabbitwho, Jan 7, 2012
3
votes

It would not be a great conflagration here in Schools because we are all on

holidays and the school term in Victoria does not start until Wednesday the

6th February ,I think New South Wales is the same , Queensland starts on

the 23rd January a Monday so there will be very little work done on that day .

As for the rest of us we can probably all take a well needed rest and read a

book , in Spanish of course. wink red face

updated Jan 9, 2012
posted by ray76
¿Un libro? ¿Qué es ese? Estoy bromiando :) ¿Cómo estas querido? - nonombre, Jan 6, 2012
Soy feliz porque de las buenas palabras mis amigos ha escritá. And I am looking forward to visiting Jennyo next week . - ray76, Jan 6, 2012
Ray, I like your approach....by the way, you said February 6th?! Nice, it's one of the greatest days of the year mate!!! :) Abrazos de EEUU - Jason7R, Jan 9, 2012
2
votes

Wikipedia was supposed to shut down today, but it only shut down in English and if you disable javascript it works the same as usual. What a joke, either you care or you don't care. You can't half care, it's like they hiccuped in protest.

updated Jan 19, 2012
posted by rabbitwho
The point wasn't to "shut down", but to ensure anyone using the site would encounter the message. They say that explicitly. - pesta, Jan 18, 2012
What can we do to avoid it? +_+ Internet works great the way it is :O: - 00a4c226, Jan 18, 2012
Ah that's okay then Pesta, my interent wasn't working properly yesterday, it made dial up speed look like a dream come true, so I couldn't get round to the details. - rabbitwho, Jan 19, 2012
2
votes

Excuse me, but last time I noticed I didn't live in North Korea. The government isn't supposed to come and block websites without trial or notification. However, there has already been legislation (NDAA, signed into law on December 31st, 2011) like this passed - not having to do with the internet, per say, but it follows in the same type of legislation - censorship. This law allows for anyone who

was part of or substantially supported al-Qaeda, the Taliban, or associated forces that are engaged in hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners," and anyone who commits a "belligerent act" against the U.S. or its coalition allies

to be arrested by the military and held without trial! Commits a "belligerent act" against the U.S. or it's allies? How nebulous is that? I don't like terrorists and I'm not in league with them but I DO NOT want ANYONE being arrested and being held indefinetly without trial.

NDAA passed both the House and the Senate because nobody actually heard about it. It was never in the news. I only bring this up because SOPA is just like this bill. It's unconstitional and it's censorship. I for one totally support this blackout because people need to know about SOPA. If NDAA can pass the House and the Senate so can this if people don't protest.

Some interesting info on NDAA, SOPA, and the blackout:

Wikipedia article on NDAA

Foxnews Article on SOPA Blackout

Business Insider on NDAA and SOPA

updated Jan 18, 2012
edited by Jadey7
posted by Jadey7
I feel like we are becoming a totalitarian State. With cellphones and monitoring cameras, etc. there is no privacy left, either! Why should draconian legislation be passed, too? Eventually it will make it impossible to sustain intelligent life. - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
We can't let the governents (and they ALL do it) use our fear of things like terrorisim or child abuse to manipulate us, you can't punish everyone because of a tiny tiny minority, you're right this isn't North Korea, or worse, an airport! - rabbitwho, Jan 10, 2012
It was in the news a lot. - lorenzo9, Jan 18, 2012
2
votes

I'll just wash the car and desanitize the bathroom or clean out drawers or something- even knit and watch telelnovelas per espanol. You like Comisario Rex? I don't understand half of what they say (Iwould if it were written) but it's fun to immerse myself. There's this one guy on Desafio Extremo and he is a castillian fisherman, boy, is he hard to understand, plus he gets so excited and goes so fast.

The easiest for me is Planeta Feroz. Maybe I take solace in the simplicity of the animals and their basic predicaments. manada that's my favorite word - herd.

updated Jan 10, 2012
edited by tuscantory
posted by tuscantory
We could all tape ourselves learning to play an instrument and then upload all our videos playing "twinkle twinkle little star" l - rabbitwho, Jan 7, 2012
Good one, Rabbit!! - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
Or we could upload something which is still copywritten, in protest! - rabbitwho, Jan 10, 2012
2
votes

Has somebody been pulling one of your long furry ears Rabbitwho - maybe it's April Fool's Day in Ireland!!

updated Jan 9, 2012
posted by caza
Don't I wish!! - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
2
votes

This is garbage!

January 23rd is a Monday!!!! People need these websites, especially AOL, Yahoo, and Google for school and work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

alt text

What about non-US residents?

updated Jan 9, 2012
edited by SonrisaDelSol
posted by SonrisaDelSol
any site based in the US could be permanently shut down under this law and as it stands the government wouldn't have to give any explanation or give them a chance to defend themselves - rabbitwho, Jan 6, 2012
i think that's the reason why the protest appears to be worldwide and not just in the US. But you never know! - rabbitwho, Jan 6, 2012
I haven't read about any site being "shut down"... it did say that the ISP could block any site that had illegal content on it, though - NikkiLR, Jan 7, 2012
If this piece of crap is passed, >.< - NikkiLR, Jan 7, 2012
**block any foreign site - NikkiLR, Jan 7, 2012
That's the point, Sonrisa. You won't have any of those sites if this legislation passes!! :- - territurtle, Jan 9, 2012
1
vote

And what about tumblr? I know for a fact that thousands of copyrighted pictures are reblogged and posted every day there, usually whaty happens is the user who posted the pic is contacted, and they label it "copyrighted by.." .

So what happens if the government gets involved? At this point, hardly anyone takes offense at the spread of copyrighted materials. Tumblr does have some rules about this, like a limit on how many music tracks can be posted per day (one), but it's a very free site! Personally, I view it as a way to gain popularity for artists, writers, musicians; it's a free way to spread your content.

If SOPA is passed, however, tumblr would certainly be permanently shut down, or at the very least, changed drastically.

Blogging sites like this are (to me) a great example of free speech. We get to post our thoughts and share what we like, promote people, make contests, use our creativity.

How come the government gets to restrict this?

Copyright issues aside, when did it become okay for government to decide who gets to say what?

updated Jan 18, 2012
posted by kiersten11
We don't want such restrictions in our lives :O I don't want to feel like I am living in Cuba or Venezuela >_ - 00a4c226, Jan 18, 2012