Past Perfect Subjunctive Question

Question

The past perfect subjunctive makes sense to me, but shouldn't there be a second past perfect subjunctive category in the conjugation list? In addition to the Hubiera, Hubieras, Hubiera, ... ect. version shouldn't there be a Hubiese, Hubieses, Hubiese, ... ect. version as well?

I may be missunderstanding your question, but I was taught that the -se and -ra endings were essentially the same. Maybe the -se would be used more in Spain. Where I live, all I hear is the -ra. - Pinolero, Jan 4, 2012

I reread your question. Maybe it was simply a heads up to the moderators to add them... - Pinolero, Jan 4, 2012

Answer 1

Sí, pero creo que es un poco raro.

Mira: Conjugación del verbo hablar

Answer 2

The past perfect subjunctive makes sense to me, but shouldn't there be a second past perfect subjunctive category in the conjugation list? In addition to the Hubiera, Hubieras, Hubiera, ... ect. version shouldn't there be a Hubiese, Hubieses, Hubiese, ... ect. version as well?

The "se" and "ra" versions have the same meanings. You see the "se" version alot in writing (books, subtitles, newspapers) but I have never heard it spoken in Mexico.

I agree it´s spoken rarely, but not unheard of in Mexico. It is, however, understood by all educated people. I find the "se" version very refreshing - 005faa61, Jan 5, 2012

Answer 3

I'm pretty you're right, we haven't really learned it that well but you sound pretty right for the second part. Hope that helps.